第 460 期·中文精讀

納倫德拉·莫迪:印度總理——權力、民主、戰爭與和平

Narendra Modi: Prime Minister of India – Power, Democracy, War & Peace

印度總理談執政理念與民主制度的運作,涉及邊境安全、對外關係以及印度在世界中的定位。

官方音訊00:00 / --:--
中文精讀由 AI 基於原始訪談改寫,非官方翻譯,可能存在偏差或錯誤;表述以原音訊與官方文稿為準。說明

Lex Fridman 在鏡頭前已經斷食45個小時,只喝水。他說這是為了向莫迪表達敬意,也是想讓自己進入對話需要的狀態。莫迪的回應帶著一點長輩式的溫和,先道謝,然後把話題接了過去。

在印度,斷食跟節食是兩回事。莫迪把它講成一門科學。他說,一個因為窮困而被迫餓肚子的人,我們不會說他在斷食。斷食是一個主動的、有準備的過程。

他的準備方式很具體。正式斷食前五到七天,他會做一系列阿育吠陀和瑜伽的清理練習,儘可能多地喝水,先把身體內部"重置"一遍。等到真正開始,感官會變得異常敏銳。你會聞到水本身的氣味,那是平時喝水時根本注意不到的東西。有人端著茶從身邊走過,你能捕捉到那股香氣,像聞咖啡一樣。一朵看過無數次的小花,今天再看,細節全都浮出來了。

他還提到一件更奇怪的事:斷食期間思維會加速,視角會重新整理,人會開始往框子外面想。他自己經常有這種體驗,不確定別人是否也這樣。

斷食從來不會讓我變慢。我照常工作,有時候還做得更多。(莫迪)

他一年裡的斷食安排是這樣的:六月中旬開始進入 Chaturmas,雨季消化變慢,每天只吃一頓,一直持續到十一月的排燈節之後,前後四到四個半月。九月或十月的 Navratri,九天完全不吃固體食物,只喝熱水。三月或四月的 Chaitra Navratri,九天每天只吃一種水果,選了木瓜就九天只吃木瓜,一天一次。這些習慣他已經堅持了五十到五十五年。

一個很生動的片段來自奧巴馬。莫迪第一次以總理身份訪美,白宮安排了正式晚宴,隨行人員裡有人小聲提醒:總理不吃東西。這讓美方有點為難,怎麼在國宴上招待一個大國的領導人卻不端菜?坐下來之後,侍者給莫迪端來一杯熱水。他轉向奧巴馬開玩笑:看,我的晚餐到了。後來他再去美國,奧巴馬還記得這事,笑著說上次你在斷食,這次我們吃午飯,你沒斷食,得吃雙份。

一雙白帆布鞋和粉筆灰

莫迪出生在古吉拉特邦北部梅薩納縣的瓦德納加爾(Vadnagar),一個歷史比大多數人想象中更厚重的小鎮。他上學時,村裡有位老人常跟孩子們說,看到有刻字的石頭、有銘文的石雕,就搬到學校那個角落去。日子久了,他才慢慢意識到自己住的地方有多古老。

後來他才知道,中國拍過一部關於這裡的電影,主角是玄奘。這位中國僧人在很多個世紀以前在這裡待過相當長的時間,那時瓦德納加爾是佛教學習的重鎮。他當上首席部長之後推動了大規模考古發掘,結果證實曾有成千上萬的佛教僧侶在此求學,佛教、耆那教和印度教傳統在這裡長期共存。挖出來的證據把這座城市的連續歷史推到了2800年前。現在那裡建了一座國際級博物館。

他講自己的家世時用的全是細節。一家人擠在一間沒有窗戶、只有一扇小門的屋子裡,那個地方可能比他現在坐著接受採訪的房間還小。父親每天凌晨四點到四點半出門,走很長的路,依次去過幾座廟,再到自己的店。父親穿村裡手工做的皮底鞋,走路發出"篤、篤、篤"的聲音,村裡人靠這個聲音就能判斷時間:哦,達莫達爾先生上路了。

關於貧窮,他給了一個類比。一個穿慣了高階鞋子的人,突然沒鞋穿,會覺得難受。可他們家從來沒穿過鞋,那要怎麼知道穿鞋是件大事?沒有比較的參照物。他說,困難的生活條件沒有在他們心裡留下印記。

上學路上碰到舅舅,舅舅吃了一驚:你就這樣去學校,不穿鞋?於是給他買了一雙白帆布鞋,大概十到十二盧比。白鞋容易髒,他放學後不急著回家,一個教室一個教室地撿老師扔掉的粉筆頭,拿回家泡在水裡搗成糊,用來把鞋重新刷白。

沒有熨斗的年代,他把水燒在銅壺裡,用鉗子夾住銅壺壓衣服,然後去上學。他說那時候不覺得自己窮,也不去比較別人的日子。

一個可能的僧侶,和一個實際的總理

十七歲那年,莫迪離家,在喜馬拉雅山區遊蕩了大約兩年,過著近似苦行者的生活,常常在露天過夜。他不太願意多談這段經歷,但在追問下給了一些外部細節。

他做過很多身體實驗。冬天不算特別嚴酷,但十二月的夜裡還是咬人,他有時故意睡在露天,不蓋任何東西,就看身體能扛到什麼程度。圖書館、池塘、洗全家的衣服、游泳,構成了他當時的日常。

對他影響最大的讀物是斯瓦米·維韋卡南達(Swami Vivekananda)。他講了一個維韋卡南達早年的故事。維韋卡南達的母親病了,他去找師父羅摩克里希納,希望得到幫助,甚至為此爭辯。師父讓他去迦梨女神像前求。他去了,在神像前坐了整整幾個小時,深度入定,回來之後師父問:你求了嗎?他說沒有。第二天、第三天再去,每次都空手而回。站在神面前卻開不了口要東西,那一刻在他心裡點了一把火。莫迪的解讀是:從那一刻起,給予的精神誕生了。

如果我的心裡只有索取的飢渴,那份飢渴永遠不會結束。(莫迪)

在羅摩克里希納傳教會期間,他遇到了一位對他影響很深的人,斯瓦米·阿特瑪斯瓦南達(Swami Atmasthananda),這位僧人活到將近一百歲。莫迪當首席部長時,老人常來看他。有一次老人看著他問:你為什麼來這裡?你有更大的使命。你的優先選項是自己的安好,還是社會的福祉?維韋卡南達說過的一切都是為了社會的福祉,你是要去服務別人的。莫迪說他當時有點失落,本來是來求指引的,結果只得到幾句話。

Lex 順著這個點提出一個假設:如果沒有這位僧人,世界上可能會有一個僧侶莫迪,而不是總理莫迪。莫迪的回答是,從外面看,人們叫他領導人、總理、首席部長,那是別人的視角。往裡看,只有一條不變的精神承諾。當年幫母親照顧孩子、在喜馬拉雅山遊蕩的那個莫迪,和今天坐在這個位置上工作的莫迪,是同一個人。衣服變了,生活方式變了,白天說的話變了,工作的性質變了,核心沒變。

"全世界勞動者團結起來"這句話被改了一個詞

八歲那年,莫迪加入了國民志願服務團(RSS)。他記得村裡有個叫馬科希(Makoshi)的人,揹著一面小手鼓,用低沉有力的嗓子唱愛國歌曲,每到一個村子就搭臺演出。莫迪說自己像追星一樣追著他跑,整晚整晚地聽。

村裡有 RSS 的分支,孩子們在那裡打球、唱愛國歌。RSS 教給他的第一條價值觀是:無論做什麼,都要帶著目的去做。讀書是為了學到足以報效國家的程度,鍛鍊身體是為了讓身體能服務國家。

RSS 快滿一百年了。莫迪給了一組數字:志願者發起的"印度服務團"(Seva Bharati)在貧民聚居區運營大約12.5萬個服務專案,全部不靠政府資助;"瓦瓦西·卡良·阿什拉姆"(Vanvasi Kalyan Ashram)在偏遠部落地區建了超過7萬所"單教師學校",其中一些專案靠海外支持者每月捐出十到十五美元維持,口號是"這個月少喝一瓶可樂,把錢捐給一所單教師學校";"維迪亞·巴拉蒂"(Vidya Bharati)運營近2.5萬所學校,教育約300萬名學生。

工會這一段很有意思。RSS 培養的志願者組織的印度工會聯合會,大約有5萬個分會,成員數以百萬計,規模可能是全球最大的勞工組織。但莫迪強調的地方在別處:口號上的一次詞序調換。左翼傳統勞工運動喊的是"全世界勞動者,團結起來",先聯合,別的以後再說。RSS 系統的工會喊的是"勞動者,團結世界"。

別人說"全世界勞動者團結起來",我們說"勞動者團結世界"。看起來只是詞的位置換了一下,背後是一次很大的意識形態轉變。(莫迪)

他的解讀是:前一種邏輯是把人聚起來去對抗什麼,後一種邏輯是讓勞動者本身成為粘合劑。

一百多種語言,一條看不見的線

Lex 問,是什麼把印度這個高度碎裂的國家黏在一起。莫迪的切入點落在名字上。

印度有一百多種語言,幾千種方言。有句老話,每走20英里,語言變、習俗變、飯菜變,連穿衣風格都變。從南到北差異巨大。但往下挖一層,會找到一條共同的線。比如羅摩的故事,全印度都能聽到他的名字。你仔細看,從泰米爾納德邦到查謨和克什米爾,到處都有人的名字裡帶著"羅摩"這個詞根:古吉拉特邦叫 Rambhai,泰米爾納德邦叫 Ramachandra,馬哈拉施特拉邦叫 Rambhau。

再比如沐浴時的一段儀式,人們會念誦恆河、亞穆納河、戈達瓦里河、薩拉斯瓦蒂河、納爾默達河、印度河、高韋裡河的水同時在場的禱詞。一段關於洗澡的唸白,把整個國家的地理裝了進去。

婚禮和法事開始時,人們先祈請整個宇宙,從 Jambudweep、Bharatkhand、Aryavrat 一路收窄,收到具體的村莊、具體的家族,最後祈請家神。這套做法今天仍在印度每個角落每天發生。莫迪的觀點是:西方和全球主流模型把國家只看成行政系統,印度歷史上行政系統換過很多輪,邦國林立、統治者無數,真正的統一在文化紐帶裡。商羯羅建立的四大朝聖地,至今仍有人從拉梅斯瓦拉姆帶水到喀什,再從喀什帶水回去。

甘地做了什麼別人沒做到的事

談到甘地,莫迪先講了同鄉關係。甘地也生在古吉拉特,母語也是古吉拉特語。他做過律師,在海外生活多年,本來有很多好機會,是內心那種責任感讓他放棄一切,把自己交給印度。

莫迪對甘地的分析有一個非常清晰的角度:甘地把自由運動變成了一場群眾運動,方法是他重新定義了"參與"。他告訴教師,你們的工作就是自由鬥爭的一部分;他告訴紡線織布的人,你們是自由戰士;他告訴照顧麻風病人的人,你們的服務就是印度走向自由的一步。每一件日常勞動都被編進了獨立運動這張網,普通人因此變成了戰士。

英國人到最後一刻都沒完全弄明白,鹽稅遊行裡的一撮鹽,怎麼能點燃這麼大一場革命。(莫迪)

他還講了一個甘地的逸事。甘地穿著腰布去白金漢宮見國王,很多人驚訝。甘地的回應大意是:你的國王身上的衣服夠我們兩個人穿了。莫迪說這就是他那種帶著頑童氣的機智。

莫迪從甘地身上繼承的方法論是"不把一切交給政府"。他說自己是社會變革力量的堅定信仰者。

平視:既不仰視,也不俯視

Lex 丟擲一個經典問題:在世界舞臺上談判,被愛和被怕,哪個更管用?莫迪先糾正了比較本身,他說甘地不屬於二十世紀,他的相關性會延續好幾個世紀。

然後他回到2013年。那一年他的政黨宣佈他作為總理候選人,批評者的攻擊點非常集中:莫迪只是個邦一級的領導人,他懂什麼外交政策?他懂全球地緣政治嗎?幾乎每次採訪都會被問。他當時給出的答案,後來成了他外交政策的骨架。

印度既不允許自己被俯視,也不會仰視任何人。印度會平視對手。(莫迪,2013年)

十多年過去,他說這句話仍然是核心。國家利益永遠第一,但貶低別人、說別人壞話,既不符合他的文化價值,也不符合他的傳統。他給自己的外交貼的標籤是一串"一":一個太陽、一個世界、一張電網;同一個地球、同一個健康;G20 峰會的主題是同一個地球、同一個家庭、同一個未來。

他對聯合國的評價很直接:這類組織誕生於一戰之後,沒有跟上時代,適應能力的缺失引發了關於它們是否還有意義的全球討論。

我的立場就是和平

Lex 問的是俄烏戰爭。莫迪先用身份回答:他代表的是佛陀的土地,是甘地的土地,印度文化裡沒有鼓吹衝突的基因。然後才講操作。

他說自己和俄羅斯、烏克蘭都保持著密切關係,所以可以坐下來對普京說,現在不是打仗的時候;也可以友好地對澤連斯基說,兄弟,無論世界上有多少人站在你這邊,戰場上永遠不會出現解決方案,解決方案只會出現在烏克蘭和俄羅斯都坐到談判桌前的時候。烏克蘭可以和盟友進行無數次討論,但那些討論不會結果,因為談判必須包含雙方。

我一直說,我站在和平這一邊。我不站在中立的位置。我有立場,我的立場就是和平。(莫迪)

談巴基斯坦,莫迪的語氣明顯變重。他先往回翻歷史:1947年之前,大家在獨立鬥爭中並肩作戰,整個國家都在等著慶祝自由。然後他講分治之後從巴基斯坦開來的、裝滿傷員和屍體的列車,講當年印度的決策者同意了分治、同意了單獨建國的要求。他的判斷是,對方拿到自己想要的東西之後,並沒有選擇和睦共處,而是一次次選擇與印度為敵,發動代理人戰爭。

他把這條線索拉到了全球:9·11的主謀本·拉登最後藏在哪裡?藏在巴基斯坦。他的結論是,恐怖主義和恐怖主義思維在巴基斯坦有很深的根,今天它不只是印度的麻煩,而是全球動盪的一箇中心。他也承認,他曾親自前往拉合爾,當上總理後特別邀請了巴基斯坦參加就職典禮,想翻過新的一頁,但每一次促進和平的善意嘗試都碰上了敵意和背叛。

Lex 問了個輕鬆的問題:印度和巴基斯坦,誰的板球隊更強?莫迪的回答很有分寸,他說自己不是技術專家,只有真正懂技術的人才能判斷誰的技戰術更好,但有時候結果會自己說話。前幾天兩隊剛打過一場,結果說明了一切。

關於足球,他提到1980年代那一代人心中的英雄是馬拉多納,今天這一代人會立刻說出梅西。他還講了一個片段:他訪問中央邦一個叫沙赫多爾(Shahdol)的部落地區,那裡站著一群穿著運動服的男孩,他問你們從哪來,回答是"小巴西"。因為那個村子四代人都在踢球,出過近80名國家級球員,每年辦比賽,周邊村子會有兩萬到兩萬五千人來看。

休斯頓體育場裡的那一圈

談到特朗普,莫迪講的是休斯頓"你好,莫迪"(Howdy Modi)那場活動。整個體育場坐滿,印度僑民來了很多人,兩人都講了話,特朗普坐在臺下聽莫迪講。莫迪說這是他的謙遜,美國總統坐在觀眾席上聽另一個國家的領導人講話,是個不尋常的舉動。

講完之後,莫迪下臺去道謝,隨口提了一句:如果不介意,我們要不要在體育場裡走一圈,這麼多人在這兒,去打個招呼。在美國的政治生活裡,總統走進幾千人的群眾幾乎是不可能的。特朗普沒有猶豫就答應了,整個安保團隊被打了個措手不及。莫迪說那一刻對他觸動很大,因為這說明這個人有勇氣,自己做決定,也足夠信任他。

莫迪還講了第一次進白宮的經歷。當時關於特朗普的報道已經很多,他自己也被各種簡報"預告"過。結果他一進門,對方就打破了所有正式禮節,親自帶他參觀。讓莫迪印象深刻的是,特朗普手裡沒有任何講稿或提示卡,也沒有助手跟著,自己指著說這裡是林肯住過的地方,解釋法庭為什麼設計得那麼長,指著桌子說哪位總統在這裡簽過字、哪一天籤的。莫迪的判斷是,這個人尊重總統這個位置,也和美國曆史有很深的連線。

特朗普第一任期結束後,拜登上臺,四年裡兩人沒見過面。但只要遇到雙方都認識的人,特朗普都會說一句:莫迪是我的朋友,替我問候他。莫迪說這種事發生過幾十次,很少見。

特朗普公開說過,莫迪是比他強得多的談判者。莫迪不肯接這個話,只說那是對方的謙遜,然後給出自己的原則:談判時永遠把國家利益放第一位,為此在每個場合都為印度發聲,但不以傷害別人為目的,所以沒人會因此被冒犯。

1億個不存在的名字

莫迪主動把特朗普的"政府效率部"(DOGE)和自己的執政經驗聯絡起來。他說2014年上臺時,他想做的事情之一,就是把國家從一些根深蒂固的壞做法裡解放出來。

他舉的例子是福利欺詐。某些政府計劃的福利被大量根本不存在的人領走,有幽靈名單,有人還沒結婚就領到了寡婦撫卹金,有人沒有任何殘疾卻領著殘疾撫卹金。他啟動審查之後發現,系統裡有大約1億個虛假或重複的名字,這些名字被清理掉了。

接著是直接福利轉移(DBT)。每一盧比從德里發出,直接到該拿到的人手裡,中間沒有滲漏。他說這一項為國家省下了近3萬億盧比,被砍掉的正是中間環節。

他還提到政府採購平臺 GeM 提高了競爭和透明度,取消了4萬項不必要的合規要求,廢除了近1500條已經沒有任何用處的舊法律。他把這套動作概括為:把治理從無謂的支配和低效中解放出來。

中國:把分歧控制在不變成爭端

談中印關係,莫迪先擺歷史。兩國都是古老文明,幾個世紀以來互相學習,古代記錄顯示,某一個時期印度和中國加起來佔全球 GDP 的一半以上。他說兩國之間沒有真正的衝突史,有的只是互相學習和理解,佛教一度在中國有巨大影響,而那種哲學原本來自印度。

然後是現實。他承認邊境存在長期爭議,2020年的邊境事件造成了兩國關係的顯著緊張。但在他與習近平最近的會面之後,邊境局勢回到了正常,雙方正努力把狀態恢復到2020年之前。他說信任、熱情和能量會慢慢回來,但需要時間,因為中間隔了五年。

差異是自然的。兩個鄰國之間,偶爾的分歧一定會發生。哪怕在一個家庭裡,也不是每件事都完美。關鍵是不讓分歧變成爭端。(莫迪)

他對二十一世紀的判斷是:這是亞洲的世紀,他希望印度和中國進行健康、自然的競爭。競爭本身沒問題,但不能變成衝突。

2002年:把12到15個月的背景先擺出來

Lex 提到2002年古吉拉特騷亂,超過1000人死亡,莫迪當時是首席部長,同時說明印度最高法院在2012年和2022年兩次認定莫迪與暴力事件無關。

莫迪沒有直接回應指控,他先要求把時間線擺出來。1999年12月24日,一架從加德滿都飛往德里的印度客機被劫持,改道飛往阿富汗,降落在坎大哈,數百名印度乘客被扣為人質,全印度陷入巨大的不安。2000年,德里的紅堡遭恐怖襲擊。2001年9月11日,美國雙子塔被襲。2001年10月,查謨和克什米爾議會遭襲。2001年12月13日,印度議會遭襲。八到十個月裡,一連串重大恐怖襲擊,死傷和恐懼不斷累積。在那種氛圍裡,最小的火星也能點著東西。

就在這個背景下,2001年10月7日,他被交給古吉拉特首席部長的職責。當時的古吉拉特剛從一場大地震中恢復,那是上個世紀最大的地震,數千人死亡。他上任後的第一件大事是災後重建。他說自己此前完全沒有政府經驗,沒有在政府任過職,沒有參加過選舉,沒有當過邦議員,人生第一次要面對選舉。

2002年2月24日,他第一次成為民選代表。2月24、25或26日,他第一次走進古吉拉特議會。2月27日,議會開預算會期。就在那一天,成為民選代表才三天,戈德拉(Godhra)事件發生了,有人被活活燒死。

他接著給出一個資料反駁:外界把2002年當成古吉拉特最大規模騷亂的說法是誤傳。翻2002年之前的資料會發現,古吉拉特長期頻繁發生騷亂,宵禁經常在某個地方實施,放風箏比賽、腳踏車相撞這種小事都可能引爆社群衝突。2002年之前,古吉拉特發生過250多次較大規模的騷亂,1969年那次持續了將近六個月。

在古吉拉特,騷亂曾經每年都以某種方式發生。但2002年之後,22年裡沒有發生過一次大規模騷亂。古吉拉特一直很平靜。(莫迪)

他給出的治理邏輯是:放棄"世界銀行式的政治",改成"和大家一起、為所有人發展、從所有人那裡獲得信任、靠所有人努力"。從"安撫的政治"轉向"抱負的政治"。他還說,真正有責任的人已經被法院追究了。

蒼蠅和蜜蜂

Lex 問莫迪怎麼處理和批評的關係。莫迪的回答很乾脆:如果要用一句話概括,他歡迎批評,他堅信批評是民主的靈魂。他還引了本國典籍的說法,永遠把批評者放在身邊,因為他們能讓你更快改進,讓你用更好的見識去做民主的工作。他甚至說自己希望批評更多、更尖銳、更有見地。

他真正不滿的是別的東西。他說今天看到的很多內容算不上批評。真正的批評需要紮實的研究、深入的分析,需要從假象裡把真相挑出來。而現在人們找捷徑,不做研究,跳過分析,不去找真正的弱點,直接跳到指控。他強調指控和批評是兩回事,他收到的那些是指控,不是批評。

關於媒體的標題黨,他的態度分兩層。如果有人靠吸引眼球的標題、玩文字遊戲,他說自己不太在意。但如果背後有刻意的議程,真相被故意忽略,那造成的傷害可以持續幾十年。

他講了一個在倫敦的故事。一次由當地古吉拉特語報紙主辦的活動上,因為臺下坐的多是記者,他隨口說了一個比喻:我們應該有哪一種新聞業,像蒼蠅還是像蜜蜂?蒼蠅落在髒東西上,把髒東西四處傳播;蜜蜂落在花上,採集花蜜,再把甜味分享出去。但如果真出了錯,蜜蜂蜇人的那一下足夠厲害,能讓你三天沒臉見人。

結果有人只擷取了比喻的一半,製造出一場大風波。莫迪說他根本沒有在貶低誰,他只是在講蜜蜂的力量:小小一蜇,能讓人躲起來好幾天,那才是新聞業該有的力度。

9.8億註冊選民和一間森林裡的投票站

莫迪說,相信民主的人都該聽聽接下來這段。2024年大選,註冊選民9.8億。每個人有註冊身份證,所有細節都在一個龐大的資料庫裡。這個數字是整個北美人口的兩倍,超過整個歐盟的總人口。其中6.46億人走出家門,頂著五月的高溫去投票,有些地區氣溫達到40度。這個選民基數是美國人口的兩倍。

投票站超過一百萬個。印度有超過2500個註冊政黨,900多個24小時新聞頻道,每天出版的報紙超過5000種。有些國家要花幾個月才宣佈選舉結果,印度在一天之內就公佈了。

關於偏遠地區的投票站,他講了兩件事。選委會用直升機運送投票站。阿魯納恰爾邦有記錄在案的最高海拔投票站。古吉拉特邦的吉爾森林裡,為一個選民單獨設了一個投票站,那人住在荒無人煙的地方。他說印度選舉委員會為自由公正的選舉樹立了全球標杆,世界頂級大學應該把它當作案例來研究。

"首席僕人",以及從不孤獨

Lex 問了一個很直接的問題:這麼多年的權力,會不會腐蝕心智?莫迪不接受"有權勢"這個說法。他說自己從不自稱有權勢,他自稱"首席僕人"(prime servant),服務是他工作倫理的指導原則。他說自己進入政治的動機從來都是服務,跟權力遊戲無關。他說自己在意的是"生產力",權力一直不在他的關注清單上。

Lex 接著問:你把整個靈魂都給了工作,你會不會孤獨?莫迪說他從不感到孤獨,因為他信奉"一加一"的哲學。第一個"一"代表莫迪,第二個"一"代表全能者。他說自己從來不是一個人,因為那位一直陪著他。

疫情期間封城、出行受限,他設計了一套完全透過視訊會議運轉的治理模式。另一件事是,他從全黨志願者名單裡挑出70歲及以上的人,一個一個打電話。這些人很多出身非常普通,莫迪問他們的健康、家人的情況、所在地區的狀況。他說這些人被觸動,因為總理在疫情期間會來問候他們。他每天打大約40個電話,整個疫情期間沒有斷過。

關於工作強度,他的回答方式很有意思。他說自己不覺得只有自己在工作,他看周圍的人,總覺得他們比自己更努力。他想到農民在露天下日復一日地勞作,想到士兵在雪地、沙漠甚至水下日夜不停,想到每個家庭裡的母親和姐妹,最早起床、最晚睡覺,照顧所有人還要應付社會責任。想完這些,他的問題是:我怎麼能睡?我怎麼能休息?

他講2014年競選時立下的三條:為國家工作絕不落後,絕不懷惡意行事,絕不為個人利益做任何事。他說24年過去了,這三條標準一直在用。

拉馬努金、人工智慧,和"資訊不等於知識"

Lex 作為數學愛好者提到斯里尼瓦薩·拉馬努金(Srinivasa Ramanujan),這位出身貧寒、自學成才的印度數學家。莫迪說他非常敬重拉馬努金,因為他相信科學與靈性之間有深層連線,很多科學上先進的頭腦,靈性上也很先進。拉馬努金曾說自己的數學想法來自他敬拜的女神,也就是想法來自靈性紀律。莫迪對"紀律"的定義是:把自己完全投入一件事,投入到與工作合為一體。

要清楚區分資訊和知識。有些人把資訊誤當成知識,隨身帶著大量資訊,但資訊本身不等於知識。知識要透過加工、反思和理解慢慢長出來。(莫迪)

關於 AI,莫迪在巴黎 AI 峰會上說過一句話,他說自己說這話是負責任的:不管世界怎麼做 AI,缺了印度就不完整。Lex 追問,莫迪反問:你覺得誰能完全靠自己開發 AI?他舉了峰會上的例子,讓 AI 生成一個人用左手寫字的影象,它總是生成用右手寫字的人。

莫迪的論點是,AI 發展本質上是一次協作。印度在做的不光是理論模型,AI 應用也做進了具體場景,還建了一個市場化的模式讓 GPU 算力覆蓋到社會的各個部分。他拿5G舉例:世界一開始認為印度落後很多,但印度一啟動就成了全球鋪開5G最快的國家。他講了一位美國公司高管來訪時說的話:在美國招工程師,收到的簡歷最多填滿一個房間;在印度做同樣的事,一個足球場都裝不下。

談到"AI 會不會取代人類",他的回答是把問題翻過來。他說每一個時代,技術和人類之間都會形成競爭氛圍,有時被描述成衝突,好像技術要挑戰人類的存在。但每一次技術前進,人類都會適應,並且保持領先一步。他認為 AI 真正的力量在於,它逼著人類重新反思"人到底是什麼"。

人類有一種天生的能力,去關心彼此。現在誰能告訴我,AI 有這種能力嗎?(莫迪)

一場考試和一位老師的日記本

莫迪每年辦"考試對話"(Pariksha Pe Charcha),直接和學生交流。他給出的問題診斷是:社會上形成了一種奇怪的心態,學校用排名衡量自己的成功,家庭因為孩子名次高而感到驕傲,因為這被認為能提升教育和社會地位。孩子於是覺得,自己整個人生就押在十年級和十二年級的考試上。

他反覆講的一點是:考試適合評估某個領域的知識,但不能成為衡量一個人整體潛力的唯一標尺。有人學術上分數不高,卻能在板球場上打出一百分,因為那才是他真正強的地方。當注意力轉向真正的學習,分數往往會自然上升。

他講了兩個關於老師的小故事。一位老師讓一個孩子第二天帶10顆鷹嘴豆,不多不少;讓另一個孩子帶15粒米;讓第三個帶21顆綠豆。每個孩子回家數自己那份,自然就記住了數字,也認識了豆子。回到學校,老師再說:拿出10顆鷹嘴豆、3顆、2顆綠豆。孩子在遊戲裡學會了數學。

另一位老師在開學第一天放了一本日記在桌上,說誰到得最早,就寫下帶自己名字的一句話,後面的同學要接著寫相關的內容。莫迪起初每天早早衝到學校,就為了寫第一句。他寫過類似"今天的日出很美,讓我充滿能量"的句子。幾天之後他意識到,因為自己出門前就想好了要寫什麼,創造力並沒有提高。於是他改成故意最後到,先讀別人寫了什麼,再給出自己最好的一句。創造力反而上來了。

關於學生怎麼應對壓力,他給的建議很具體:先充分準備,只有準備好了才能不焦慮;如果考試時筆突然不出墨,或者覺得鄰座的人讓你不舒服,或者凳子晃了,注意力就全跑掉了,這本身就是自信不足的訊號。真正準備好的人,花一分鐘深呼吸,讓心靜下來,重新聚焦,慢慢讀題,把時間按題分配。

關於怎麼學習,他講了一個轉變。他說自己過去主要靠閱讀學習,但這些年越來越多靠"完全在場"來學習。見到一個人,就把全部注意力給對方,不接電話、不看訊息。這種完全聚焦讓他能很快抓住新概念。他還說,光有知識照不亮路,必須泡進實踐的流裡。你不可能只靠讀賽車手的傳記學會開車,得自己坐上駕駛座,還得敢冒險,不能被對事故和死亡的恐懼擋住。

活在當下的人,才是把生命活得最滿的人。因為每一刻活過去,就已經滑進了過去。(莫迪)

生死、冥想,和一片葉子上的水滴

Lex 問了一個很人性的問題:你會不會思考自己的死亡,會不會怕死?莫迪反過來問他:生命和死亡是一枚硬幣的兩面,哪一面更確定?Lex 答:死亡。莫迪說,正是如此。既然只有死亡是確定的,為什麼要害怕確定的事?生命本身是死亡的一句低語,但它也被註定要繁盛。所以應該去豐富、提煉、提升自己的生命,在死亡敲門之前活得完整、活得有目的。

談到冥想,莫迪說這個詞已經被用得太濫,幾乎成了陳詞濫調。在印度語言裡他們叫"dhyan",直接說冥想會讓人覺得沉重,好像必須開悟才行。他的定義很簡單:讓自己從分心中解放出來。上課時你的心飄到課間休息,滿腦子只有午飯,那就是不冥想。

他講了一段喜馬拉雅的親身經歷。一位智者教了他一個非常實用的技巧,一點也不"靈性"。山裡有很多小溪,智者把一片大葉子擺好去接溪水,下面放一隻倒扣的碗,讓

文稿來自 Lex Fridman 官網公開發布的官方 Transcript(含說話人與時間戳)。
Narendra Modi (00:00:00): My strength lies not in my name, but in the backing of 1.4 billion Indians and thousands of years of timeless culture and heritage. So wherever I go, I carry with me the essence of thousands of years of Vedic tradition, the timeless teachings of Swami Vivekananda and the blessings, dreams, and aspirations of 1.4 billion Indians. When I shake hands with the world leader, it’s not Modi, but 1.4 billion Indians doing so. So this isn’t my strength at all. It is rather the strength of India. Whenever we speak of peace, the world listens to us, because India is the land of Gautama Buddha and Mahatma Gandhi, and Indians aren’t hardwired to espouse strife and conflict. We espouse harmony instead. Narendra Modi (00:01:06): We seek neither to wage war against nature, nor to foster strife among nations. We stand for peace, and wherever we can act as peacemakers, we have gladly embraced that responsibility. My early life was spent in extreme poverty, but we never really felt the burden of poverty. You see, someone who is used to wearing fine shoes will feel their absence when they don’t have them, but for us, we had never worn shoes in our lives. So how would we even know that wearing shoes was a big deal? We weren’t in a position to compare. That’s just how we lived. Narendra Modi (00:01:56): When I became Prime Minister, I especially invited Pakistan to my swearing-in ceremony so we could turn over a new leaf, yet every noble attempt at fostering peace was met with hostility and betrayal. We sincerely hope that wisdom prevails upon them and they choose the path of peace. I believe even the people of Pakistan long for peace. Look, regarding what you said about criticism and how I deal with it. If I had to summarize in one sentence, I welcome it. I have a strong belief that criticism is the soul of democracy. I want to tell all the young people the following. No matter how dark the night may seem, it is still just night, and morning is bound to come. Lex Fridman (00:03:07): The following is a conversation with Narendra Modi, the prime Minister of India. It was one of the most moving conversations and experiences of my life. Allow me here to say a few words about it. Please skip ahead straight to our conversation, if you like. Narendra Modi’s life story is incredible. He rose from poverty to lead a nation of 1.4 billion people, the biggest democracy in the world, where he won epic-scale elections for Prime Minister three times. As a leader, he fought for ideas that unite his nation of India, a nation that is composed of a large number of highly varied and disparate cultures and peoples, who have a long history marked by religious, social, and political frictions. He is known for taking decisive, at times controversial actions for which he is loved by hundreds of millions of people, and is also criticized by many. We discuss all of this at length in this conversation. On the world stage, he is respected as a peacemaker and friend by most major world leaders, even those whose nations are at war with each other, from the United States to China, to Ukraine and Russia, to Israel, Palestine and the Middle East, and everywhere else. Now, at this moment in history, it is clear, at least to me, that the flourishing of human civilization hangs in the balance, with several wars on the brink of escalation to regional and even global conflict, rising tensions between nuclear powers, technological developments from AI to nuclear fusion that aim to completely transform society and geopolitics as we know it, and of course, generally increasing political and cultural turmoil. Lex Fridman (00:05:05): So now more than ever, we need great leaders, great peacemakers who build bridges, not destroy them, who may preserve the identity of their nations, but still celebrate the common humanity of all of us, all people on earth. For this and many other reasons, this conversation with Prime Minister Modi was one of the most remarkable I’ve ever had. You may hear such words and think that I’m just enamored by power or access. No, never was, never will be. I do not idolize anyone, especially those in power. I’m generally skeptical of power, money, and fame because of their natural corrupting influence on the mind, the heart, the soul of a person. Lex Fridman (00:05:57): The whole point of all the conversations I’ve had in my life, on mic and off mic, is that I try to see and explore the full complexity of every human being, the good and the bad. I believe we’re all the same in a deep fundamental sense, all capable of good, all capable of evil, all carry stories of pain and stories of hope. Whether you’re a world leader or a truck driver, a coal miner, or a farmer in the American Midwest. And by the way, I will be talking to a lot of the latter kind of folk this year off mic, and maybe even on mic, as I travel the US and the world. My brief statements here about Narendra Modi are about both him as a leader, and especially him as a human being. In the extensive time I spent with him, I spoke with him off mic and on mic. Lex Fridman (00:06:56): It was a deeply personal human interaction characterized by warmth, kindness, humor, inner and outer peace, and absolute focus on the conversation between us in the present moment as if nothing else existed. I have heard from many people that he treats everyone he meets in this empathic way, no matter where they come from or what their position is in this world. So for those and many other reasons, this really was an incredible experience. I will never forget. Oh, and by the way, we make captions and voiceover audio tracks available in English, Hindi and other languages. You can also listen to the original mixed language version where I speak English and Prime Minister Modi speaks Hindi. Separately, you can choose to turn on subtitles in your preferred language. Lex Fridman (00:07:52): On YouTube, you can switch between language audio tracks by clicking the settings gear icon and clicking audio track, and then selecting the language you prefer. For fully English overdub, select English. For fully Hindi overdub select Hindi, and to listen to the original mixed language version where I speak English and Prime Minister Modi speaks Hindi, please select Hindi Latin audio track, so you can listen either to a version that is all one language or to the original mixed language version with subtitles in your preferred language. The default is English overdub. Our thanks to ElevenLabs and a great team of translators, we do our best to bring the Prime Minister’s voice to life with AI voice cloning in English. Lex Fridman (00:08:41): I promise that we will continue to work very hard to break down the barriers that language creates, and try to make these conversations as accessible as possible to everyone in the world. Anyway, let me pause one more time to say a big thank you. What a wild ride this life has been. It’s an honor for me to be on it with all of you. I love you all. This is the Lex Fridman podcast, and now, dear friends, here’s the Prime Minister of India, Narendra Modi. Lex Fridman (00:09:19): So, I should also say I’m fasting right now. It’s been almost two days, 45 hours, so just water, no food in honor of this conversation, just to get in the right mindset, get into the spiritual level. I’ve read that you often fast for many days. Can you explain why you fast, and where does your mind go when you fast? Narendra Modi (00:09:42): First of all, I’m truly pleasantly surprised and honored that you’re fasting, all the more because it feels like you’re fasting as a tribute of respect for me. So, I express my deepest gratitude to you for doing this. In India, our religious traditions are actually a way of life. Our Supreme Court once gave a brilliant interpretation of Hinduism. They have stated that Hinduism is not about rituals or methods of worship, but rather it’s a way of living, a philosophy that guides life itself. And in our scriptures, there is deep discussion on elevating the body, mind, intellect, soul, and humanity. They outline various paths, traditions, and systems to achieve this, and fasting is one of them, but fasting alone isn’t everything. In India, whether you see it culturally or philosophically, sometimes I see that fasting is a way to cultivate discipline. Narendra Modi (00:11:28): If I put it in simple terms, or explain it to the viewers who are unfamiliar with India, it is a powerful tool to bring both the inner and outer self into balance. It shapes life in profound ways when you fast. You may have noticed, as you said, you’ve been fasting on water for two days. Every single one of your senses, especially smell, touch and taste, becomes highly sensitive. You may even notice the subtle aroma of water itself, something you probably never noticed before when drinking it. If someone walks past you carrying tea, you will catch its aroma just like you would with coffee. A small flower you’ve seen before, you will see it again today, but now you can perceive its details more vividly. Your senses become extra sharp, highly aware, and fully tuned in, and their capability to observe and to respond multiplies, and grows sharper. I have personally often experienced this. Another thing I’ve experienced is that fasting can greatly accelerate the thinking process, and can give a fresh perspective. You start thinking outside the box. I don’t know if everyone experiences this, but I certainly do. Most people assume that fasting simply means giving up food or not eating, but that’s just the physical aspect of fasting. If someone is forced to go without food due to hardship with an empty stomach, can we call that fasting? Fasting is actually a scientific process. Whenever I fast for an extended period, I prepare my body in advance. For five to seven days before the fast, I follow various Ayurvedic practices and yoga practices, along with other traditional cleansing methods to internally reset my system. Narendra Modi (00:14:07): Before actually beginning the fast. I make sure to drink a lot of water, as much as possible. So, you could say that this detoxification process helps prepare my body in the best possible way. And once I begin fasting, for me, it’s an act of devotion. For me, fasting is a form of self-discipline. For me personally, even while I go about doing my daily activities during a fast, my mind remains deeply introspective and focused inward, and that experience is profoundly transformative for me. My practice of fasting didn’t come from reading books, listening to sermons, or following a tradition just because my family happened to have observed it. It came from my own personal experience. Narendra Modi (00:15:10): During my school days, there was a movement inspired by Mahatma Gandhi’s vision, his vision of cow protection. The government had not enacted any laws at the time. At the time, people across the country observed a one-day fast by gathering in public places in silent protests. We were just kids, probably had just finished primary school. Something inside me said, “I should be part of this,” and that was the first time in my life I experienced fasting. At such a young age, I felt neither hunger nor any desire for food. Instead, I felt a new awareness, a surge of energy within me. Narendra Modi (00:16:04): So, I became convinced that fasting is a science far beyond just skipping meals. It is something far greater than that. Then gradually, I refined my body and mind through various experiments. Over time, it became a long and disciplined journey for me, and one thing is certain. Fasting never slows me down. I work just as much as usual. Sometimes I even work more. And another fascinating thing I’ve noticed is that when I need to express my thoughts, I’m amazed at where they come from and how they flow. It’s truly an incredible experience. Lex Fridman (00:16:58): So you still do meetings with world leaders, you still manage the affairs of India. You still carry out your role as a leader on the world stage, all fasted, and sometimes nine days? Narendra Modi (00:17:14): Well, this practice has a long historical context. I hope it may be interesting for those listening. There is an ancient tradition in India called Chaturmas. During the monsoon season, we know that the digestion tends to slow down, and so in this season, many people in India follow the practice of eating only a single meal within 24 hours. For me, this starts around mid-June and goes on until after Diwali around November. For about four to four and a half months, I follow this tradition of eating only once in 24 hours. Then comes the Navratri Festival in India, which usually falls in September or October. During this time, the whole country celebrates Durga Puja, a festival of strength, devotion, and spiritual discipline. This lasts for nine days. Narendra Modi (00:18:17): During this time, I completely abstain from food and only drink hot water. Although drinking hot water has always been a part of my daily routine, my past lifestyle was such that I naturally developed this habit over time. Then in March or April, another Navratri occurs called Chaitra Navratri. This year, it will likely begin around March 31st. During this nine-day fast, I eat only one specific fruit, once a day. So for those nine days, if let’s say I choose papaya, then for all nine days, I won’t touch anything else. Just papaya. That too, I eat only once a day. That’s how I follow my nine-day fasting routine. So there are numerous fasts I keep throughout the year, and this has become a deeply ingrained tradition in my life. Perhaps I can say that I’ve been following these practices for 50 to 55 years. Lex Fridman (00:19:25): Has there been times when you met with a world leader and completely fasted, and maybe what do they think about that? What do they think about your ability to do that kind of thing? And you’re right, I should mention that from even my two days, my ability to be present, my ability to sense everything, sharply focus on this experience is elevated. But yes, is there stories with a world leader that maybe jumped to mind when you were fasted? Narendra Modi (00:19:55): Well, most of the time I don’t even let people know about it. It’s my personal matter, so I never publicized it, but people gradually started finding out. It became known only after I became Chief Minister and Prime Minister. Otherwise, it was purely personal. But now that it’s out in the open, I don’t mind sharing. If someone asks, I tell them so it might be useful to them, because it’s not my personal property. It’s my experience, and if that can help someone, why not share it? After all, my life has always been devoted to the well-being of others. Narendra Modi (00:20:34): For example, after I became Prime Minister, I had a bilateral meeting at the White House with President Obama, and he had also arranged a formal dinner. Then as discussions between the two governments progressed, someone said, “Please join us for dinner.” To which another replied, “But the Prime Minister doesn’t eat.” This left them a bit concerned. How do you host the leader of such a major nation at the White House without serving food? When we sat down, they brought me a glass of hot water. I turned to President Obama and jokingly said, “Look, my dinner has arrived,” as I placed the glass in front of me. Later when I visited again, he still remembered. He smiled and said, “Last time you were fasting, this time we’re having lunch. Since you’re not fasting, you’ll have to eat twice as much.” Lex Fridman (00:21:38): Let’s go to the beginning. You rose from humble beginnings to lead the world’s largest democracy. So, I think there’s a lot of people for whom this is truly inspiring. Your family was a very modest means, and you grew up in a one-room house with a mud floor, your whole family living there. Tell me about your childhood. How did those humble beginnings shape your outlook on life? Narendra Modi (00:22:07): My birthplace is in Gujarat, specifically in North Gujarat, in Mehsana district, in a small town called Vadnagar. Historically, this town holds great significance, and so Vadnagar is where I was born and completed my early education. Looking at the world as I understand it today, I can reflect on my childhood and the unique environment I grew up in. My village had certain fascinating aspects, some of which are quite rare, even globally. When I was in school, there was an elder in our village who would regularly tell students, “Listen, kids, wherever you go, if you find a carved stone, or you find a stone with inscriptions on it or anything with engravings, bring it and place it in this corner of the school.” Over time, my curiosity grew and I started to understand. I realized that my village had a rich and ancient history. Discussions at school often revealed more fascinating details about its past. Later I learned that China even made a film about it. I had read in a newspaper about a film that mentioned the Chinese philosopher Hiuen Tsang, who had spent a considerable amount of time in my village, having arrived there many centuries ago. Back then, it was a major center for Buddhist learning. That’s how I first learned about it. And perhaps around the 1400s, it was a prominent Buddhist educational hub. Narendra Modi (00:24:22): There was a victory monument from the 12th century, a temple from the 17th century, and in the 16th century, two sisters, Tana and Riri, who were renowned musicians. As I uncovered these history traces, I grasped the depth of our heritage. So when I became chief minister, I initiated large-scale excavation projects. The findings from these very projects confirmed that thousands of Buddhist monks had at one time studied there. It was a place where Buddhist, Jain and Hindu traditions co-existed harmoniously, and for us, history wasn’t just confined to books. Every stone spoke. Every wall had a story to tell, and so when we began the large-scale excavation work, we uncovered findings that hold immense historical significance. Narendra Modi (00:25:40): So far, they have discovered evidence dating back 2,800 years, proving that this city has remained unbroken and eternal for all those 2,800 years. They have discovered solid proof of how its development unfolded over these centuries. Now, an international-level museum has been established there, open to visitors, especially for archeology students. It has become a major area of study. So the place where I was born holds its own unique historical significance. I see it as my good fortune. Some things in life unfold beyond our understanding. Kashi became my realm of duty. Now, Kashi is also eternal. Kashi, also known as Benares, or Varanasi, is an eternal city that has remained vibrant and alive for centuries. Narendra Modi (00:26:45): Perhaps it was some divine design that led a boy born in Vadnagar to eventually make Kashi his realm of duty, living in the embrace of Mother Ganga. When I think about my family, my father, my mother, my siblings, my uncles, aunts, grandparents, we all grew up together in a small house. The place we lived was likely even smaller than where we are sitting now. There was no window, just a small door. That’s where I was born. That’s where I grew up. Now, when people talk about poverty, it’s natural to discuss it in the context of public life, and by those standards, my early life was spent in extreme poverty, but we never really felt the burden of poverty. Narendra Modi (00:27:50): You see, someone who is used to wearing fine shoes will feel their absence when they don’t have them. But for us, we had never worn shoes in our lives. So how would we even know that wearing shoes was a big deal? We weren’t in a position to compare. That’s just how we lived. Our mother worked incredibly hard. My father, too. He was extremely hardworking, and he was also extremely disciplined. Every morning around 4:00 or 4:30 AM he would leave the house, walk long distances, visit several temples, and then reach his shop. Narendra Modi (00:28:39): He wore traditional leather shoes, handmade in the village. The shoes were very tough and sturdy, making a distinct tock, tock, tock sound when he walked. People in the village used to say that they could tell the time just by hearing his footsteps. ” Oh, yes,” they would say, “Mr. Damodar is on his way.” Such was his discipline. He worked tirelessly, late into the night. Our mother too, ensured that we never felt the struggles of our circumstances, but despite everything, these challenging circumstances of living in scarcity never left a mark on our minds. I remember in school, the idea of wearing shoes never even crossed my mind. Narendra Modi (00:29:40): One day, while I was on my way to school, I ran into my uncle on the way he saw me and was surprised, “Hey, you go to school like this, without shoes?” So at that time, he bought me a pair of canvas shoes and made me wear them. Back then, they must have cost around 10 or 12 rupees. But here’s the thing. They were white canvas shoes, and they would quickly get stained. So what did I do? In the evening, after school was over, I would stay back for a while. I would go from classroom to classroom, collecting leftover pieces of chalk that the teachers had discarded. I would take the pieces of chalk home, soak them in water, mix them into a paste and polish my canvas shoes with it, making them bright white again. Narendra Modi (00:30:49): For me, those shoes were a treasured possession, a symbol of great wealth, and I don’t exactly know why, but from childhood, our mother was extremely particular about cleanliness. Perhaps that’s where we inherited that habit, too. Not sure how I picked up the habit of dressing neatly, but it’s been there since childhood. Whatever I wore, I made sure it looked proper. Back then, as you can imagine, we didn’t have any arrangements for ironing clothes. So instead, I would heat up water in a copper pot, hold it with tongs, and press my clothes myself. Then I’d head off to school. That’s how I lived, and I found joy in it. We never thought about being poor, or judged about how others lived or what their struggles were. Narendra Modi (00:31:45): We lived carefree, enjoying whatever little we had and kept working hard. Never once did we complain about these things. And all these aspects of my life, whether you call it fortune or misfortune, unfolded in such a way in politics that they started coming to light. Because when I was taking my oath as Chief Minister, TV reporters went to my village, questioned my childhood friends, went to capture videos of my home. That’s when people started asking, “Who is this and what background he is coming from?” Before that, very few knew much about my life. That’s just how my journey has been. My mother possessed an innate spirit of caring for others’ well-being. It was woven into the very fabric of her being. She possessed knowledge of traditional remedies and healing practices, and would treat children with these home remedies. Every morning before sunrise, around five o’clock, she would start treating them, so all the children and their parents would gather at our home, little children crying, and we had to wake up early because of it. Narendra Modi (00:33:02): And we had to wake up early because of it. Meanwhile, my mother would continue treating them with care. This spirit of service, in a way, was nurtured through these experiences. A sense of empathy for society, the desire to do good for others, these values were instilled in me from my family. I believe that my life has been shaped by my mother, my father, my teachers, and the environment I grew up in. Lex Fridman (00:33:33): There’s a lot of young people listening to this that are truly inspired by your story. From those humble beginnings to the leader of the biggest democracy in the world, what can you tell to those young folks who are struggling, who are lost in the world, who are trying to find their way? What advice could you give them? Narendra Modi (00:34:00): I want to tell all the young people the following. No matter how dark the night may seem, it is still just night, and morning is bound to come. That’s why we need patience and self-confidence. Yes, the challenges are real, but I am not defined by my circumstances. I am here for a purpose, sent by a higher power, and I am not alone. The one who sent me is always with me. This unwavering faith should always remain within us. Difficulties are a test of endurance. They are not meant to defeat me. Hardships exist to make me stronger, helping me grow and improve, not to leave me feeling hopeless or discouraged. Personally, I see every crisis, every challenge as an opportunity. Narendra Modi (00:35:12): So, to all young people, I say, have patience. There are no shortcuts in life. At our railway stations, there hangs a sign for those who habitually cross the tracks instead of using the bridge, it reads, “Shortcut will cut you short.” I would tell young people the same, shortcut will cut you short. There are no shortcuts in life. Patience and perseverance are essential. Whatever responsibility we are given, we must pour our heart into it. We should live it with passion. Enjoy the journey and find fulfillment in it. I truly believe that if this mindset is cultivated, it transforms life. Similarly, abundance alone is not enough. There is no guarantee of success. Even a wealthy person who indulges in comfort and idleness will eventually wither away. Narendra Modi (00:36:09): Instead, he must decide, “Yes, I may have resources around me, but I must use my abilities to grow them further. I must contribute more to society with my own strength. Even if I am in a good position, there is still so much more to do. Even if I am not in a good position, there is still so much work to do.” That’s what I believe. I have also noticed that some people tend to think, “I’ve learned enough. That’s it.” But one should never let the student within them die. Learning should never stop. I believe that as long as I am alive, I must have a purpose. Perhaps I exist to keep learning, to keep growing. Now, my mother tongue is Gujarati, and we were not very familiar with the Hindi language, nor did we know how to speak it eloquently or communicate effectively. But as a child, I used to sit at my father’s tea shop, and at that young age, I got the chance to meet so many people. And every time, I learned something from them, I observed their ways of speaking, their expressions. These things taught me a lot, even though I wasn’t in a position to apply it then, I thought, “If I ever get the chance, why not? Why shouldn’t I present myself well?” So, I believe the desire to learn should always remain alive. And another thing I’ve observed is that most people dream about achieving something or becoming someone. They set big targets and when they fall short, they feel disappointed. Narendra Modi (00:38:19): That’s why whenever I get a chance to talk to my friends, I tell them, instead of dreaming about getting and becoming, dream of doing something. If you focus on doing something, and let’s say your goal is to reach 10, but you make it to eight, you won’t feel discouraged. You’ll still work toward 10 with determination. But if your dream is only to become something and it doesn’t happen, even your achievements may feel like a burden. That’s why we must adjust our mindset in life. Instead of thinking about what I got or didn’t get, the mindset should be what can I give? Because true contentment doesn’t bloom on its own. It grows from the depth of what you give. Lex Fridman (00:39:16): And I should say that this young kid, one of the things I’ve dreamed of doing is to do this very thing, to talk to you today. So, this is very surreal. At 17, another fascinating part of your life. You left home and spent two years roaming in the Himalayas, searching for purpose, for deeper truth, for God. So, not much is known about this period of your life. You lived a nomadic, minimalist existence, very much like a yogi, often sleeping without a roof over your head. What are some memorable spiritual moments, rituals, experiences from that time? Narendra Modi (00:39:59): It seems like you’ve put in a lot of effort. Look, I don’t usually talk much about this, but I can share a few external aspects of it. I grew up in a very small town. Our life was all about being part of a community. We lived among people, surrounded by them. That was just how life was. There was a library in the village, and I used to go there often to read books. Whenever I read something from the books, I often found myself feeling inspired, thinking, “Why shouldn’t I shape my own life like that?” That desire was always there. When I used to read about Swami Vivekananda or read about Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj, I would often wonder, “How did they live? How did they build such remarkable lives?” And for that, I constantly experimented on myself. Most of my experiments were physical in nature, testing my body’s limits. Narendra Modi (00:41:20): For example, where I lived, winters weren’t too harsh, but December nights could get quite cold. But still, at night, the cold would bite. It was natural. So, sometimes I would decide to sleep outside in the open with nothing to cover myself, just to see how my body endures the cold. So, from a very young age, I would often experiment with my body, and this became a regular thing for me. For me, going to the library, reading extensively, visiting the pond, washing the family’s clothes, and swimming became part of my routine. Swimming was my main physical activity. All of these things were deeply connected to my life. Later as I read Vivekananda, I became even more drawn to his teachings. One time I read about Swami Vivekananda, his mother was ill. So, he went to Sri Ramakrishna Paramahamsa for guidance. He would argue with him, debate with him. In his early days, he would often argue with him, questioning everything intellectually. Narendra Modi (00:43:10): He said, “My mother is sick. If I were earning, I could take better care of her.” Sri Ramakrishna said, “Don’t bother me with all this. Go to Goddess Kali. She is there. Ask her for what you need.” And so, Swami Vivekananda went and sat before Goddess Kali’s idol for hours, and he immersed himself into deep meditation. After a few hours when he returned, Ramakrishna asked him, “So, did you request the goddess?” Swami Vivekananda replied, “No, I didn’t.” Ramakrishna said, “Go again tomorrow. She will fulfill your request. Ask her.” He went the next day and then again the day after. But each time, he found himself unable to ask for anything. His mother was unwell and he needed help, but when he sat before Goddess Kali, he was completely absorbed in her presence, and yet he could not bring himself to ask for anything. Narendra Modi (00:44:29): Each time he returned empty-handed. He told Sri Ramakrishna, “I came back empty-handed. I didn’t ask for anything.” To stand before the divine goddess and not be able to ask for anything, that moment, that experience lit a flame inside him. There was a spark in his life. And from that came the spirit of giving. I believe that perhaps that small incident in Vivekananda’s life left an impression on me too. The thought of, “What can I give to the world?” Maybe true contentment comes from giving. If my heart is only filled with the hunger to receive, that hunger will never end. And within that realization came the idea of Shiva and living being as one. If you wish to serve Shiva, serve all living beings. Recognize the unity between the divine and the living. True non-duality is experience through this realization. I would often lose myself in such thoughts. My mind naturally drifting in that direction. Narendra Modi (00:45:58): I remember an incident in the neighborhood where we lived, just outside there was a Lord Shiva temple. One day a saint came to stay there. So, that saint used to engage in meditation and spiritual practices. I started feeling drawn to him thinking perhaps he possessed some spiritual energy. I had only read about Swami Vivekananda, never seen such figures in real life. During Navratri, he was fasting and he had placed sorghum grains on his hand, a common tradition in our culture. In a way, sprouting seeds on your palms and sleeping like that for nine or 10 days, it was a kind of spiritual vow, and this saint was observing it. During those same days, my maternal uncle’s family was preparing for my aunt’s wedding. Everyone from my home was going to my uncle’s house for the wedding. Narendra Modi (00:47:07): Now, for any child, visiting an uncle’s house is always exciting. But I told my family, “I’m not going. I’ll stay here and I will take care of Swamiji. Since he has these grains on his hand, he can’t eat or drink, so I will take care of him.” So, as a child, I chose not to attend the wedding. I stayed back serving Swamiji instead. Somehow my mind was naturally drawn in that direction. At times, whenever soldiers from my village came home during their holidays, they would walk around in their uniforms with such pride. I would run behind them all day thinking, “Look at them. They are serving the nation.” So, there was always a strong feeling inside me to do something meaningful. I didn’t fully understand what it would be, and I didn’t have a roadmap. There was a hunger within me, a deep longing to understand life, to explore its meaning. So, I just set out and began the journey. Narendra Modi (00:48:11): During my time in the mission, I came across remarkable saints. They showered me with love and blessings. Among them, I formed a special bond with Swami Atmasthanandji. He lived for nearly 100 years, a life full of wisdom and service. In his final years, I deeply wished for him to stay with me at the Prime Minister’s residence, but his responsibilities were vast and he couldn’t come. However, back when I was chief minister, he used to visit and I was fortunate to receive his blessings and guidance. He once looked at me and said, “Why have you come here? You have a greater purpose to fulfill. Is your priority your own well-being? Or is it the welfare of society? Whatever Swami Vivekananda said was for the betterment of society. He said you are meant to serve others.” So, I remember feeling a bit disheartened at that moment. I had come seeking guidance, but all I got were words. Narendra Modi (00:49:20): So, I continued on my journey, wandering from place to place. I spent time in the Himalayas embracing the solitude of the mountains. I met many remarkable individuals along the way. Some were great ascetics, people who had renounced everything, but still my mind remained restless. Perhaps it was my age of curiosity, of wanting to learn, to understand. It was a new experience, a world shaped by the mountains, by ice, by the towering snow-covered peaks. But all of this played a huge role in shaping me. It strengthened me from within and enabled me to discover my inner power. Practicing meditation, waking up in the sacred pre-dawn hours, bathing in the cold, serving people with devotion and naturally tending to elderly saints became a seamless part of who I was. Once, a natural calamity struck the region, and I immediately devoted myself to helping the villagers. So, these were the saints and spiritual masters with whom I stayed from time to time. I never remained in one place for long, I kept moving, constantly wandering. That was the kind of life I lived. Lex Fridman (00:50:45): And for people who don’t know, that moment in the Ramakrishna Mission Ashram with the monk, Swami Atmasthananda, as you mentioned, he helped steer you towards a life of service. So, there’s another possible life that could have been where you take Sannyasa, you give away everything, and you’re a monk. So, we could have had a monk, Narendra Modi, and Prime Minister Narendra Modi, and he helped you take the decision to live a life of service at every scale Narendra Modi (00:51:21): From the outside, people may call me a leader. Some call me the prime minister. Others call me the chief minister, and that’s how they see me from their perspective. But deep within, there is only an unwavering spiritual commitment. The Modi, who lovingly helped his mother care for children during their treatments, tending to them with patience and compassion. The Modi who wandered through the Himalayas. And the Modi who now works from this seat of responsibility. They are all tied together by the same inner consistency. Every action is dedicated to serving others. People may see a stark difference between a saint and a leader, but to me, there is no real difference. Yes, the attire changes, the way of life changes. The words spoken throughout the day shift and the nature of work evolves. But the core of my being remains unchanged, carrying out every responsibility with the same sense of calm, focus, and dedication. Lex Fridman (00:52:33): Another part of your life of who you are is you’ve spoken your whole life about putting your nation of India above all else. When you were eight, you joined the RSS, which espouses the idea of Hindu nationalism. Can you tell me about RSS and what impact they had on who you are and the development of your political ideas? Narendra Modi (00:52:58): Ever since childhood, I always had the habit of staying engaged in something or the other. I remember there was a man named Makoshi. I don’t quite recall his full name. I think he was part of the service group, Makoshi Soni or something like that. He used to carry a small drum-like instrument called the Tambourine with him, and he used to sing patriotic songs in his deep, powerful voice. Whenever he came to our village, he would hold programs in different places. I would run after him like a crazy fan just to listen to his songs. I would spend entire nights listening to their patriotic songs. I enjoyed it. I don’t even know why, but I just did. In our village, there was a branch of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, where we played sports and sang patriotic songs. Something about those songs touched me deeply. They stirred something inside me, and that’s how I eventually became part of the RSS. One of the core values that were instilled in us at RSS was, whatever you do, do it with a purpose. Even while studying, study with the goal of learning enough to contribute to the nation. Even when you exercise, do it with the purpose of strengthening your body to serve the nation. This is what we were taught. And today, RSS is a massive organization. It is now nearing its 100th anniversary. Such a massive volunteer organization likely doesn’t exist anywhere else in the world. Millions of people are connected to it, but understanding RSS is not that simple. One must make an effort to truly grasp the nature of its work. More than anything, the RSS provides you with a clear direction toward what can truly be called a purpose in life. Secondly, the nation is everything, and serving the people is akin to serving God. Narendra Modi (00:55:11): This is what has been said since the Vedic Era. What our sages have said, what Vivekananda said and what the RSS echoes. A volunteer is told that the inspiration he gains from RSS is not just about attending the one-hour session or wearing the uniform. What matters is what you do for society. And today, inspired by that spirit, many initiatives are thriving. Like some volunteers established an organization called Seva Bharati. This organization serves the slums and settlements where the poorest people live, which they call service communities. To my knowledge, they run approximately 125,000 service projects without any government assistance, solely through community support. They spend time there, teach the children, care for their health, instill good values and work towards improving cleanliness in these communities. Running 125,000 social service projects is no small feat. Narendra Modi (00:56:20): Similarly, some volunteers nurtured by RSS are dedicated to serving tribal communities through Vanvasi Kalyan Ashram. They live among the tribal people, working for their welfare. They have established over 70,000 one-teacher schools in remote tribal regions. There are also some people in America who show their support for this cause and contribute donations of about $10 or $15. And they say, “Skip a Coca-Cola this month. Don’t drink Coca-Cola and donate that money to a one-teacher school instead.” Now, imagine 70,000 one-teacher schools dedicated to educating tribal children. Some volunteers have founded Vidya Bharati to revolutionize education. Today they run nearly 25,000 schools educating around 3 million students, and I believe that millions of students have benefited from this initiative, receiving quality education at an incredibly low cost. Narendra Modi (00:57:28): Alongside education, values are prioritized, and students remain grounded, learning skills so they don’t become a burden on society. That is in every aspect of life, whether it’s women, youth, or even laborers, the RSS has played a role. In terms of membership size, if I may say so, we have the Indian Labor Union. It has around 50,000 unions with millions of members across the country. Perhaps in terms of scale, there is no bigger labor union in the world. But what’s interesting is the approach they take. Historically, leftist ideologies have fueled labor movements worldwide. And what has been their slogan? “Workers of the world unite.” The message was clear. Unite first and then we’ll deal with everything else. But what do the labor unions run by RSS-trained volunteers believe in? They say, “Workers unite the world.” Others say, “Workers of the world unite.” And we say, “Workers unite the world.” It may seem like just a small shift in words, but it represents a huge ideological transformation. Narendra Modi (00:58:58): The volunteers who come from the RSS follow their own interests, nature and inclination, and in doing so, they strengthen and promote these kinds of activities. When you observe these initiatives, you’ll see how over the past 100 years, the RSS has dedicated itself with the discipline and devotion of a seeker staying away from the glare of mainstream attention. I feel blessed to gain life’s values from such a sacred organization. Through the RSS, I found a life of purpose. Then I was fortunate to spend some time among the saints, which gave me a strong spiritual foundation. I found discipline and a life of purpose. And through the guidance of saints, I gained spiritual grounding. Swami Atmasthananda and others like him have held my hand throughout my journey, constantly guiding me at every step. The teachings of Ramakrishna Mission, Swami Vivekananda, and the service-driven philosophy of the RSS have played a crucial role in shaping me. Lex Fridman (01:00:17): But they’ve also helped push the idea of India. What is the idea that unifies India? What is India as a nation? What is the foundational idea that unites all of these disparate worlds and communities and cultures? What would it be? Narendra Modi (01:00:40): Look, India is a cultural identity. It is a civilization that dates back thousands of years. Consider the vastness of India, over 100 languages, thousands of dialects. India is so diverse that we have a saying that every 20 miles, the language changes, customs change, cuisine changes, even clothing styles shift from region to region. From the south to the north, you will see immense diversity across the country. But if you dig a little deeper, you will find a common thread. For example, the stories of Lord Ram can be heard everywhere in India. His name echoes in every corner of the country. But if you look closely from Tamil Nadu to Jammu and Kashmir, you will always find people whose names include Ram in some form. In Gujarat, he might be called Rambhai. In Tamil Nadu, Ramachandra, and in Maharashtra, Rambhau. Narendra Modi (01:02:07): This unique cultural bond is what unites India as one civilization. Take something as simple as bathing in water. We have a ritual where all the rivers of India are remembered. They chant, ” I am bathing with the waters of all these rivers: Ganga, Yamuna, Godavari, Saraswati, Narmada, Sindhu, Kaveri.” It’s a sentiment that unites a nation, and we have a long tradition of making such resolutions at the beginning of important events and rituals. And the resolution itself can present a historical record. And in so doing serve as a way of collecting and preserving historical data. It has been an incredibly unique system, guided meticulously by our scriptures. When someone makes a resolution, performs a Puja, or even during weddings, we start by invoking the entire universe, beginning with Jambudweep, Bharatkhand, Aryavrat, and gradually narrow it down to the village, then mentioning the specific family, and finally, we invoke the family deity. This practice is still alive, happening daily in every corner of India, but sadly, the Western and global models began viewing nations only as administrative systems. India, however, has had a variety of administrative systems throughout history, many systems were fragmented, scattered and varied across regions. Kings and rulers were numerous, but India’s unity lay in cultural bonds. Pilgrimage traditions played a key role in preserving this unity. Shankaracharya established the four pilgrimage sites. Even today, millions of people travel from one place to another for pilgrimage. In Kashi, you’ll find people who bring water from Rameshwaram to Kashi and take water from Kashi to Rameshwaram. Even if you look at our Hindu calendar, you’ll find so many things across the country that you can’t even imagine. Lex Fridman (01:04:27): If we look at the historical foundation of modern India, along with yourself, Mahatma Gandhi is one of the most important humans to have ever lived, but certainly one of the most important humans to the history of India. What do you admire about Mahatma Gandhi? Narendra Modi (01:04:55): As I had mentioned before, I was born in Gujarat, and Gujarati is my mother tongue. Mahatma Gandhi was also born in Gujarat. His native language was Gujarati too. He pursued a career as an attorney and lived overseas for several years. He had plenty of great opportunities, but the deep sense of duty within him, along with the values instilled by his family, led him to give up all comforts and devote his life to serving the people of India. He joined the struggle for India’s independence, and to this day, he continues to deeply influence the life of every Indian in some way. Mahatma Gandhi tried to live by his principles and practiced what he preached. For example, he strongly advocated for cleanliness and practiced it- Narendra Modi (01:06:03): He strongly advocated for cleanliness and practiced it himself, and he made it a point to discuss cleanliness wherever he went. Another key factor to consider is India’s fight for independence. India was ruled by the Mughals, the British, and several other foreign powers. Despite being bound by the shackles of colonial rule for centuries, the flame of independence burned brightly in every corner and nook of India, never fading, always fueling the desire for freedom. Millions of people sacrificed their lives so the light of freedom could shine on India. They laid down their lives for freedom, sacrificing their youth behind prison walls. Mahatma Gandhi also fought for India’s independence, but in his own way, indeed the other freedom fighters were brave warriors and devoted sons of Mother India. They came, they fought and their martyrdom immortalized them, and they did indeed have a lasting impact. Narendra Modi (01:07:15): But it was Mahatma Gandhi who awakened the nation, leading a mass movement fueled by truth and he wove even a sweeper into the very fabric of the freedom struggle. He told teachers their work was part of the freedom struggle. He told the people spinning thread and weaving clothes, they were freedom fighters. He told those tending to lepers that their service was a step toward India’s freedom. He viewed every task as a vital thread in the fabric of India’s independence movement, and this transformed India’s common man into a soldier in the quest for freedom. Gandhi forged a mass movement so immense that the British could never fully grasp it. The British never imagined that a pinch of salt from the Dandi March could spark a massive revolution, and he made it happen. And his life, presence, style, mannerisms all left a profound impact, and I have seen many of his stories evolve into timeless legends. Narendra Modi (01:08:24): I recall an incident from a Roundtable Conference. Yeah, I believe he was attending a Roundtable Conference. He was supposed to meet King George at the Buckingham Palace draped in his breechcloth. Mahatma Gandhi made his way to the palace. Many people were amazed that he had showed up in that attire to meet the King. Gandhi remarked he didn’t need to wear a lot of clothes. He said, “Your king is wearing enough clothes for the both of us.” This was the whimsical charm of his nature. Mahatma Gandhi possessed many remarkable qualities. His call for unity and recognition of the people’s strength still resonates with me. In everything I do, I strive to include the common man and to ensure the participation of as many as possible. I don’t believe in leaving everything to the government. I am a firm believer in the power of social change. Lex Fridman (01:09:46): So he was probably one of the greatest leaders of the 20th century. You are one of the greatest leaders of the 21st century. Those two centuries are very different, and you have been masterful in the game, in the art of geopolitics. So let me ask you, you have found a balance. So when negotiating on the world stage with super-powerful nations, is it better to be loved or feared? It seems like you are a masterclass of being loved by everybody, but everybody knows and feels the strength, so finding that balance. Can you speak to that balance? Narendra Modi (01:10:41): First and foremost, I don’t think this is a fair comparison. Mahatma Gandhi wasn’t just a 20th-century leader. His relevance transcends centuries. Mahatma Gandhi’s legacy will last for centuries to come, and he remains relevant to date. As far as I am concerned, I have a responsibility to fulfill, yet the weight of that responsibility pales in comparison to my country. I am nowhere near as great as my country, and my strength lies not in my name, but in the backing of 1.4 billion Indians and thousands of years of timeless culture and heritage. So wherever I go, I carry with me the essence of thousands of years of Vedic tradition, the timeless teachings of Swami Vivekananda, and the blessings, dreams and aspirations of 1.4 billion Indians. When I shake hands with a world leader, it’s not Modi, but 1.4 billion Indians doing so. So this isn’t my strength at all. It is rather the strength of India. Narendra Modi (01:12:10): You see, I recall something that happened all the way back in 2013. It was when my party declared I would be their prime ministerial candidate. My critics often tried to corner me on one point. It became a topic of widespread discussion, Modi is nothing more than a state leader. What does he know of foreign policy? Does he even understand global geopolitics? This was on everyone’s lips, and I was asked this question in every interview. I gave a very well-thought-out answer at the time. I said, “I won’t lay out my entire foreign policy in an interview, nor is it needed.” That said, India will neither allow itself to be looked down upon, nor will it ever look up to anyone. India will now see eye-to-eye with her counterparts. This was my belief in 2013, and it still lies at the heart of my foreign policy. For me, the country always comes first. However, to belittle someone or speaking ill of others is neither part of my cultural values nor my traditions. Moreover, our culture upholds and advocates for the welfare of mankind. Narendra Modi (01:13:45): India has always championed the ideas of global peace and brotherhood. For centuries, we have envisioned the world as one big family. Our noble ancestors envisaged the welfare of the whole world and universe, and that’s why you must have noticed, the nature of our conversations as well as the ideas that I have presented on the global stage, which are rooted in respect and positivity. For example, I spoke about the environment in one of my speeches. I proposed the concept of one sun, one world, one grid. During the COVID pandemic, I delivered a speech at the G20 summit. I put forth the vision of one health, where humans and nature would live in harmony, and I have always worked towards this. Narendra Modi (01:14:47): We hosted the G20 Summit with the motto, One Earth, One Family, One Future. We have inherited this timeless wisdom and it’s our duty to share it with the world. To give you an example, I have advocated for embracing renewable energy. We founded the International Solar Alliance with the motto, One Sun, One World, One Grid. Even when it comes to global healthcare, I had proposed One Earth, One Health. This initiative extends not only to humans, but also to all flora and fauna. I have always aimed to initiate efforts that foster global well-being, and the global community needs to join hands to accomplish that. Narendra Modi (01:15:40): We must also understand that the world has become one small village today. No country can thrive in isolation. Today we all depend upon one another. No one can make it far by themselves. That is why you must learn to synchronize with everyone and everyone else must learn to synchronize with you. That’s the only way to propel this initiative forward. Organizations like the United Nations came into being after the First World War, but they failed to evolve with the times, and this inability to adapt has sparked a global debate on their relevance. Lex Fridman (01:16:23): You have spoken about, you have the experience, you have the skill, you have the geopolitical leverage to be the biggest peacemaker in the world today, on the world stage, and there’s several wars going on. Can you maybe explain how you approach the process of making peace, helping make peace between two warring nations, for example, Russia and Ukraine? Narendra Modi (01:16:51): Well, I represent the country that is the land of Lord Buddha. I represent the country that is the land of Mahatma Gandhi. These are the great souls whose teachings, words, actions, and behavior are entirely dedicated to peace. And that is why culturally and historically our background is so strong that whenever we speak of peace, the world listens to us. Because India is the land of Gautam Buddha and Mahatma Gandhi and Indians aren’t hardwired to espouse strife and conflict. We espouse harmony instead. We seek neither to wage war against nature, nor to foster strife among nations. We stand for peace and wherever we can act as peacemakers, we have gladly embraced that responsibility. Narendra Modi (01:18:03): Returning to your example, I have a close relationship with Russia and Ukraine alike. I can sit with President Putin and say that this is not the time for war, and I can also tell President Zelensky in a friendly way that brother, regardless of how many people stand with you in the world, there will never be a resolution on the battlefield. The resolution will only come when both Ukraine and Russia come to the negotiating table. Ukraine may hold countless discussions with their allies, but it will bear no fruit. Discussions must include both parties instead. Initially, it was challenging to find peace, but now the current situation presents an opportunity for meaningful and productive talks between Ukraine and Russia. There has been a lot of suffering. Even the global south has suffered. The world has been grappling with a food, fuel and fertilizer crisis. So the global community should unite in the pursuit of peace. As for me, I have always maintained that I stand with peace. I am not neutral. I have a stance and that is peace, and peace is what I strive for. Lex Fridman (01:19:37): Another difficult historic relationship and conflict is between India and Pakistan, it’s one of the most tense conflicts in the world, two nuclear powers with strong ideological differences. You are a great peacemaker. Looking out into the future as a visionary, what do you see as the path for friendship, for peace, for good relations between India and Pakistan? Narendra Modi (01:20:09): I would like to delve into periods of our history the world may be unfamiliar with. Before 1947, during the struggle for independence, everyone was fighting side-by-side, shoulder-to-shoulder, and the nation was eagerly waiting to celebrate the freedom, the joy of independence. Now, we could have a lengthy discussion on what led to the events that unfolded, but the fact remains that the policymakers of the time agreed to India’s partition and they agreed to the Muslim side’s demand of carving out a separate nation. With hearts weighed down by grief and silent tears, Indians embraced this painful reality. However, what unfolded was an immediate heartbreaking saga of bloodshed. Trains filled with bloodied, wounded people and corpses started arriving from Pakistan. It was a harrowing sight. After getting their own way, we expected them to live and let live and yet, they chose not to foster a harmonious coexistence. Time and again, they decided to be at odds with India. They have waged a proxy war against us. Narendra Modi (01:21:57): Don’t mistake this for ideology. What kind of ideology thrives on bloodshed and the export of terror, and we are not the sole victims of this menace. Wherever terror strikes in the world, the trail somehow leads to Pakistan. Let’s take the September 11th attacks, for example. The main mastermind behind it, Osama bin Laden, where did he eventually emerge from? He had taken refuge in Pakistan. The world has recognized that in a way terrorism and the terrorist mindset are deeply rooted in Pakistan. Today, it stands as an epicenter of turmoil, not just for India but for the world. And we have repeatedly asked them what good can come from this path? We have urged them to abandon the path of state-sponsored terrorism for good, “What do you hope to gain by surrendering your nation to lawless forces?” I even personally traveled to Lahore in the pursuit of peace. Narendra Modi (01:23:11): When I became Prime Minister, I specially invited Pakistan to my swearing-in ceremony so we could turn over a new leaf. Yet, every noble attempt at fostering peace was met with hostility and betrayal. We sincerely hope that wisdom prevails upon them and they choose the path of peace. I believe even the people of Pakistan long for peace because even they must be weary of living in strife and unrest, they must have grown weary of relentless terror where even innocent children are killed and countless lives are destroyed. Lex Fridman (01:23:54): Is there some memorable stories from your past attempts to try to improve relations with Pakistan that could guide the path forward into the future? Narendra Modi (01:24:09): Like I mentioned, my first attempt at improving bilateral relations was when I invited my Pakistani counterpart to my swearing-in. It was a gesture of goodwill. It was a diplomatic gesture unlike any in decades. The very people who once questioned my approach to foreign policy were taken aback when they learned I had invited all SAARC heads of state and our then president, Mr. Pranab Mukherjee beautifully captured that historic gesture in his memoir. This was a testament to how clear and confident India’s foreign policy had become. This sent a clear message to the world about India’s commitment to peace and harmony, but we didn’t get the desired outcome. Lex Fridman (01:25:16): Maybe to ask a little bit of a lighter question, who has the better cricket team, India or Pakistan? The two teams have an epic rivalry on the pitch and more seriously, given the geopolitical tensions that you spoke to, what role do sports and cricket and football play in fostering better relations? Narendra Modi (01:25:45): I think sports have the power to energize the entire world. The spirit of sports brings people together across different nations. That’s why I would never want to see sports being discredited. I truly believe that sports play a major role in human evolution. They’re not just games, they connect people on a deeper level. Now, coming to the question of who’s better and who’s not, when it comes to techniques in sports, I’m not an expert. Only those who specialize in the technical aspects can judge which techniques are superior and who the best players really are. But sometimes the results speak for themselves. Just a few days ago, India and Pakistan played a match. The result reveals, which is the better team. That’s how we know. Lex Fridman (01:26:51): Yeah. I’ve watched this series called The Greatest Rivalry, India versus Pakistan, that describes so many incredible players, so many incredible games. It’s always beautiful to see a great rivalry. You’ve also spoken about football. Football is very popular in India. So another tough question, who is the greatest football player of all time? We’ve got Messi, Pele, Maradona, Cristiano Ronaldo, Zidane, who do you think is the greatest football player to have ever played? Narendra Modi (01:27:22): It’s absolutely true that many regions in India have a strong football culture. Our women’s football team is performing really well and the men’s team is also making great progress. But if we talk about the past, back in the 1980s, one name that always stood out was Maradona. For that generation, he was seen as a true hero, and if you ask today’s generation, they’ll immediately mention Messi. Narendra Modi (01:27:55): Now that you’ve asked, another interesting memory just came to mind. There’s a state in India called Madhya Pradesh, right in the center. There’s a district called Shahdol, a completely tribal region where a large tribal community resides. I really enjoy interacting with people from such communities, especially the self-help groups run by tribal women. So I decided to visit them and have a conversation. But when I got there, I noticed something fascinating. Around 80 to 100 young boys, kids and even some older youth all dressed in sports uniforms standing together. Naturally, I walked over to them. So I asked them, “Where are you all from?” And they replied, “We’re from mini Brazil.” I was surprised and said, “What do you mean by mini Brazil?” They said, “That’s what people call our village.” Curious, I asked, “Why do they call it mini Brazil?” They explained, “In our village, football has been played for four generations. Nearly 80 national level players have come from here. Our entire village is dedicated to football.” They also told me when we host our annual football match, nearly 20,000 to 25,000 spectators come from nearby villages to watch. Narendra Modi (01:29:20): I see the growing craze for football in India these days as a positive sign because it not only fuels passion, but also builds true team spirit. Lex Fridman (01:29:32): Yeah, football is one of the great sports that unites not just India, the whole world, and that just shows the power of what sport can do. You recently visited the United States and reinvigorated your friendship with Donald Trump. What do you like about Donald Trump as a friend, as a leader? Narendra Modi (01:29:55): I’d like to share with you an event that stands out in my memory. Perhaps from that, you’ll get a better understanding of the point I’m trying to convey. For example, we had an event in Houston, Howdy Modi. Both President Trump and I were there and the entire stadium was completely packed. A massive crowd at an event in the US is a huge moment. While packed stadiums are common in sports, this was extraordinary for a political rally. The Indian diaspora had gathered in large numbers. Both of us delivered speeches and he sat down below listening to me speak. Now, that’s his humility. The President of the United States sitting in the audience while I spoke from the stage, that was a remarkable gesture on his part. After finishing my speech, I stepped down and as we all know, security in the US is extremely strict and thorough. The level of scrutiny there is on a completely different level. I went over to thank him and casually said, “If you don’t mind, why don’t we take a lap around the stadium? There are so many people here. Let’s walk, wave and greet them.” Narendra Modi (01:31:16): In American life, it’s almost impossible for the President to walk into a crowd of thousands, but without even a moment’s hesitation, he agreed and started walking with me. His entire security detail was thrown off guard, but for me that moment was truly touching. It showed me that this man had courage. He makes his own decisions, but also he trusted me and my lead in that moment enough to have walked with me into the crowd. It was that sense of mutual trust, a strong bond between us that I truly witnessed on that day and the way I saw President Trump that day walking into a crowd of thousands without even asking security, it was truly amazing. And if you watch the video now, you’ll be amazed. Narendra Modi (01:32:15): When he was shot during the recent campaign, I saw the same resilient and determined President Trump, the one who walked hand-in-hand with me in that stadium. Even after being shot, he remained unwaveringly dedicated to America. His life was for his nation. His reflection showed his America First spirit, just as I believe in nation first. I stand for India first and that’s why we connect so well. These are the things that truly resonate. And I believe that across the world politicians are covered so much by the media that people mostly perceive each other through its lens. People rarely get the chance to truly meet or personally know one another and perhaps third-party intervention is the real cause of tensions. Narendra Modi (01:33:20): When I visited him in the White House for the first time, there was already a lot written about President Trump in the media. At that time, he was still new to office and the world had a rather different perception of him. Even I had been briefed in many different ways before meeting him, but to my surprise, the very moment I stepped into the White House, he broke all formal protocols right away. And then, he personally took me on a tour of the White House. As he showed me around, I noticed something striking, he wasn’t holding any notes or cue cards, nor was anyone accompanying him to assist. He pointed things out himself. “This is where Abraham Lincoln lived,” he said. He even explained why the courtroom was designed so long. He would point at the table and tell me which President signed here and on what date. I found that incredibly impressive. It showed how much he honored the Presidency and how respectful and deeply connected he was to America’s history. I could feel that. And he spoke to me freely, discussing many things openly. That was my experience from our first meeting. Narendra Modi (01:34:39): Later, when his first term ended, and President Biden won, four years passed, but during that time whenever someone we both knew met him, and this must have happened dozens of times, he would say, “Modi is my friend, convey my regards.” That kind of gesture is rare. Even though we didn’t meet physically for years, our direct and indirect communication, our closeness and the trust between us remained unshaken. Lex Fridman (01:35:22): He said that you’re a much tougher, much better negotiator than he is. He said this recently when you visited. What do you think of him as a negotiator and what do you think he meant about you being a great negotiator? Narendra Modi (01:35:39): Now, that’s not something I can comment on. Since it’s his graciousness and humility, it is very kind of him that he openly appreciates me on various occasions and in different contexts. But about negotiation, I always put my country’s interests first. That’s why in every forum, I speak up for India’s interest, not to harm anyone but in a positive manner and because of that, no one takes offense. People know that if Modi is present, he will strongly advocate for these things. After all, the people of India have given me this responsibility. For me, my nation is my high command and I will always honor their will. Lex Fridman (01:36:30): You’ve also had a bunch of productive meetings with several other folks on your visit to the United States, Elon Musk, JD Vance, Tulsi Gabbard, Vivek Ramaswamy. What are some things that stood out from those meetings? Maybe key takeaways, key memories. Narendra Modi (01:36:47): Look, I can say this, I have observed President Trump both during his first term and now in his second run. This time, he seems far more prepared than before. He has a clear roadmap in his mind with well-defined steps, each one designed to lead him toward his goals. I also had the chance to meet members of his team, and I truly believe he has put together a strong, capable group and with such a strong team, I feel they are fully capable of implementing President Trump’s vision based on my interactions with them. I met several people, Tulsi Gabbard, Vivek Ramaswamy, Elon Musk, and there was a family-like atmosphere, everyone had come with their families. As for Elon Musk, I have known him since my time as chief minister. He was there with his family and children, so naturally the atmosphere felt warm and friendly. Of course, we had discussions and we talked about many different topics. Now, with his DOGE mission, he is incredibly excited about how it’s progressing and honestly, it makes me happy too because when I took office in 2014, I wanted to free my country from the deep-rooted issues and harmful practices that have crept in, and I’ll continue striving to eliminate as many of them as I possibly can. For example, after I took office in 2014, I observed that back then we weren’t part of many global discussions, not like how President Trump and DOGE are being talked about today. But let me give you an example so you can see the kind of work that was done. I noticed that the benefits of certain government schemes, especially welfare programs, were being exploited by so many people who never even existed in real life… Narendra Modi (01:39:01): … who never even existed in real life. There were ghost names, pensions being issued to fake people. Widow pensions were being granted even before marriages took place, and disability pensions were given without any real disabilities. Then I launched a scrutiny process, and you’ll be shocked to know what we found. A hundred million people, a hundred million people, that’s a hundred million fake or duplicate names that I removed from the system. And because of that, we saved massive amount of money. Narendra Modi (01:39:40): Then I introduced direct benefit transfer, ensuring that every rupee sent from Delhi reached the rightful person without leakage. As a result, my country saved nearly 3 trillion rupees that would have otherwise ended up in the wrong hands. Just because of direct benefit transfer through technology, we eliminated middlemen, ensuring transparency in the system. Narendra Modi (01:40:03): I also introduced the GeM portal for government purchases, which has helped save both time and money. It has increased competition and improved quality. In India, we had an overwhelming burden of compliances. I eliminated 40,000 unnecessary compliances, and removed nearly 1500 outdated laws that served no purpose. Narendra Modi (01:40:29): So in a way, my efforts have been about freeing governance from unnecessary dominance and inefficiency. And naturally, when bold changes happen, just like DOGE’s mission, they become a topic of discussion worldwide. Lex Fridman (01:40:52): You and Xi Jinping have considered each other friends. How can that friendship be reinvigorated to help de-escalate some of the recent tensions, and resume dialogue and cooperation with China? Narendra Modi (01:41:06): Look, the relationship between India and China isn’t something new. Both nations have ancient cultures and civilizations. Even in the modern world, they play a significant role. If you look at historical records, for centuries, India and China have learned from each other. Together, they have always contributed to the global good in some way. Old records suggest that at one point India and China alone accounted for more than 50% of the world’s GDP. That’s how massive India’s contribution was. And I believe our ties have been extremely strong, with deep cultural connections. If we look back centuries, there’s no real history of conflict between us. It has always been about learning from each other and understanding one another. At one time, Buddhism had a profound influence in China, and that philosophy originally came from here. Narendra Modi (01:42:40): Our relationship should remain just as strong in the future. It should continue to grow. Of course, differences are natural. When two neighboring countries exist, occasional disagreements are bound to happen. Even within a family, not everything is always perfect. But our focus is to ensure that these differences don’t turn into disputes. That’s what we actively work toward. Instead of discord, we emphasize dialogue, because only through dialogue can we build a stable cooperative relationship that serves the best interests of both nations. Narendra Modi (01:43:35): It is true that there have been ongoing border disputes between us. And in 2020, the incidents along the border created significant tensions between our countries. However, after my recent meeting with President Xi, we have seen a return to normalcy at the border. We are now working to restore conditions to how they were before 2020. Slowly but surely, trust, enthusiasm, and energy will return. But of course, it will take some time, since there’s been a five-year gap. Our cooperation isn’t just beneficial, it’s also essential for global stability and prosperity. And since the 21st century is Asia’s century, we want India and China to compete in a healthy and natural way. Competition is not a bad thing, but it should never turn into conflict. Lex Fridman (01:44:35): The world is worried about a brewing global war. The tensions between China and the United States, in Ukraine, Russia and Europe, in Israel, the Middle East. What can you say about how we in the 21st century can avoid a global war, avoid an escalation towards more conflict, more war? Narendra Modi (01:45:07): Look, COVID exposed the limitations of every nation. No matter how much we consider ourselves as a great nation, no matter how progressive we think we are, or how scientifically advanced we believe we’ve become, everyone has their own way of looking at things. In the end, we all found ourselves on the same ground. Every country in the world faced this reality. At that time, it felt like the world would learn from it, that we would move toward a more unified world. Just as a geopolitical order emerged after World War II, many thought something similar would happen post-COVID. But unfortunately, instead of moving towards peace, the world became even more fragmented, ushering in a period of uncertainty, and the wars have only made it worse. Narendra Modi (01:46:16): I believe that modern wars are no longer just about resources or interests. Today I see so many kinds of conflicts happening. Physical battles often get discussed. Struggles are happening in every domain. International organizations that were once powerful have become almost irrelevant. No real reforms are happening. Institutions, like the UN, are failing to fulfill their roles. People, who disregard international laws and rules, continue to act freely, and no one can stop them. In such situations, the prudent choice for everyone is to let go of conflict and move toward cooperation. And a development-driven approach is the way forward. Expansionism will not work. As I’ve said before, the world is interdependent and interconnected. Every nation needs one another, no one can stand alone. And from all the different forums I attend, one thing is clear: Everyone is deeply worried about these conflicts. We can only hope that peace is restored very soon. Lex Fridman (01:47:59): I’m not very good at this. Narendra Modi (01:48:00): You keep looking at your watch. Lex Fridman (01:48:02): No, no, no. I barely know what I’m doing, Prime Minister. I’m not very good at this. Okay. You’ve been… through your career and through your life, you have seen a lot of difficult situations in the history of India. One of them, the 2002 Gujarat riots, they’re one of the most challenging periods of modern Indian history, when there was violence between Hindu and Muslim citizens of the Gujarat that led to over 1000 deaths. It revealed the intensity of religious tensions in the region. You were, as you mentioned, chief minister of Gujarat at the time. Looking back, what lessons do you draw from that time? And we should also say that India’s independent Supreme Court upheld twice, in ’12 and ’22, that you had no involvement in the violence of the 2002 Gujarat riots. But I was wondering if you could speak to the broad lessons you draw from that time? Narendra Modi (01:49:07): Look, regarding your first point, when you humbly said that you don’t know what you’re doing, that you’re not good at this, I disagree and personally feel you’ve put in tremendous care. You’ve done extensive research and have dived deeply into every small detail. So I think you’ve done very well, and all the efforts you’ve put in during our conversation and in all your conversations are appreciated. And rather than simply interviewing me, I feel you’re trying to deeply understand India. That’s why I strongly feel there’s genuine honesty in your sincere effort to uncover the truth. And for that sincere approach, I genuinely congratulate you. Lex Fridman (01:50:06): Thank you. Narendra Modi (01:50:06): Regarding the earlier events that you mentioned, like the 2002 riots in Gujarat, I’d like to paint you a clearer picture of the 12 to 15 months leading up to that, so you can fully understand the atmosphere of that time. For instance, take December 24, 1999, roughly three years earlier, an Indian flight from Kathmandu to Delhi was hijacked, redirected to Afghanistan and landed in Kandahar. Hundreds of Indian passengers were held hostage. It caused massive turmoil across India as people faced life and death uncertainty. Narendra Modi (01:51:02): Then, in the year 2000, the Red Fort in Delhi was attacked by terrorists. Yet another crisis struck the nation, intensifying fear and turmoil. On September 11th, 2001, the Twin Towers in America faced a devastating terror attack, once again shocking the entire world. Because ultimately, the people behind these attacks are driven by a similar mindset. Then in October 2001, terrorists attacked the Jammu and Kashmir Assembly. Soon after, on December 13th, 2001, India’s parliament was targeted. Narendra Modi (01:51:41): Within just eight to 10 months, these major global terrorist attacks took place, violent incidents that led to bloodshed and the loss of innocent lives. In such a tense environment, even the smallest spark can ignite unrest. The situation had already become extremely volatile. In such times, suddenly, on October 7th, 2001, I was given the responsibility of becoming chief minister of Gujarat. This was an enormous challenge. Narendra Modi (01:52:21): At that time, Gujarat was recovering from a devastating earthquake, the largest of the previous century, which had left thousands dead. My first major task as chief minister was overseeing the rehabilitation of survivors. This was a crucial task, and from day one after my oath, I immersed myself in it. I was a person who had absolutely no prior experience with government. I had never been part of any administration, never even served in government before. I had never contested an election, never even been a state representative. For the first time in my life, I had to face elections. Narendra Modi (01:53:04): On February 24, 2002, I became a state representative, an elected representative for the first time. And it was only around February 24th, 25th, or 26th that I stepped into the Gujarat Assembly for the very first time. On February 27th, 2002, we were seated in the Assembly for the budget session. And that same day, it had been just three days since I’d become a state representative, when suddenly the horrific Godhra incident occurred. It was a tragedy of unimaginable magnitude, people were burned alive. You can imagine, against the backdrop of incidents like the Kandahar hijacking, the attack on parliament, or even 9/11, and then to have so many people killed and burned alive, you can imagine how tense and volatile the situation was. Of course, this was tragic for everyone. Everyone prefers peace. Narendra Modi (01:54:27): The perception that these were the biggest riots ever is actually misinformation. If you review the data from before 2002, you will see that Gujarat faced frequent riots. Curfews were constantly being imposed somewhere. Communal violence could erupt over trivial issues, like kite flying contests or even minor bicycle collisions. Before 2002, Gujarat witnessed over 250 significant riots. The riots in 1969 lasted nearly six months. So there was a long history, long before I was in the picture. Narendra Modi (01:55:15): But that one tragic incident in 2002 became a sparking point, leading some people towards violence. Yet, the judiciary thoroughly investigated the matter. At that time, our political opponents were in power, and naturally they wanted all allegations against us to stick. Despite their relentless efforts, the judiciary analyzed the situation meticulously twice and ultimately found us completely innocent. Those who were truly responsible have faced justice from the courts. Narendra Modi (01:55:55): But the most important thing is, in Gujarat, where riots used to happen some way or the other every year, but after 2002, in 22 years, there hasn’t been a single major riot in Gujarat. Gujarat remains completely peaceful. Our approach has always been to avoid World Bank politics. Instead, our mantra has been, together with everyone, development for all, trust from all, and efforts by everyone. We’ve shifted away from the politics of appeasement to the politics of aspiration. Because of this, anyone who wishes to contribute joins us willingly. We’ve continuously strived to turn Gujarat into a well-developed state. And today, Gujarat is actively contributing toward building a developed India as well. Lex Fridman (01:56:55): A lot of people love you. I’ve got to hear from a lot of them. But there is also people who criticize you, including from the media. And folks in the media have criticized you over this 2002 Gujarat riots. What’s your relationship like with criticism? How do you deal with critics? How do you deal with criticism coming from the media or in your own inner circle or just in your own life? Narendra Modi (01:57:24): Look, regarding what you said about criticism and how I deal with it, if I had to summarize in one sentence, I welcome it. I have a strong belief that criticism is the soul of democracy. If democracy truly runs in your veins, you must embrace it. In our scriptures it’s said, always keep your critics close. Critics should be your nearest companions, because through genuine criticism, you can improve quickly, and work democratically with better insights. In fact, I believe we should have more criticism and it should be sharp and well-informed. Narendra Modi (01:58:23): But my real complaint is that nowadays what we see isn’t real criticism. Genuine criticism requires thorough study, in-depth research and careful analysis. It demands finding the truth from falsehoods. Today, people look for shortcuts, avoid proper research and skip deep analysis. Instead of identifying genuine weaknesses, they jump straight to accusations. There’s a big difference between allegations and criticism. The references you’re giving, they are allegations, not criticism. For a strong democracy, genuine criticism is necessary. Allegations benefit no one, they just cause unnecessary conflicts. That’s why I always welcome criticism openly. And whenever false accusations arise, I calmly continue serving my country with complete dedication. Lex Fridman (01:59:28): Yeah, the thing you speak of is very important to me because I admire great journalism. And unfortunately, in modern day, a lot of journalists seek clickbait headlines, make accusations, because they operate under incentive, because they want the headline, the cheap shot. I think there is room and desire and hunger for great journalists, and that requires deep understanding. And it saddens me how often… I don’t think I’m very good at this, but one of the reasons I really wanted to talk to you is because I don’t see enough high effort, deep dive research. I don’t know how many books I’ve read. I’ve read a lot in preparing, just to experience, just to try to understand. It requires a lot of preparation, a lot of work, and I would love to see great journalists do that more. And from that place, you can criticize. From that place, you can really investigate the complexity of a situation, of people in power; their strengths, their flaws, the mistakes they have made. But that requires great, great, great preparation. So I wish there was more of that, of great journalism. Narendra Modi (02:00:46): Yes. Clear, well-directed and specific criticism genuinely helps in the process of effective policymaking. It leads to a clear-cut policy vision. I specifically pay close attention to such constructive criticism. In fact, I actively welcome it. Narendra Modi (02:01:06): Regarding your point about journalistic headlines, if someone’s attracted by catchy headlines or plays with words, I honestly don’t mind that much. But when there’s a deliberate agenda behind the actions and the truth is deliberately ignored, that can cause damage that lasts for decades. If someone focuses on pleasing their readers or viewers with attractive headlines, maybe we can compromise a little. But if there’s a hidden motive, or if things are intentionally twisted to serve an agenda, that’s a serious issue worth worrying about. Lex Fridman (02:01:50): And in that, the truth suffers, I think. Narendra Modi (02:01:54): I remember once in London, I was invited to give a speech at an event organized by a Gujarati newspaper there. So during my speech, I casually said, since it was an event attended by journalists, “What kind of journalism should we have? Should it be like a fly or a bee?” I explained, “A fly sits on dirt and spreads the dirt around, but a bee lands on flowers, collects nectar, and then shares that sweetness everywhere. Yet if something wrong occurs, the bee can sting so powerfully that you’d have to hide your face for three days straight.” Narendra Modi (02:02:56): However, some people selectively picked up just half of my analogy and created a huge controversy out of it. Honestly, was I being negative about anyone? Not at all. I was simply highlighting the incredible strength of a bee, that even its small sting can leave such an impact that can make someone hide their face for days. You can’t show your face. That’s the power journalism should have. But unfortunately, some people prefer the fly approach instead. Lex Fridman (02:03:34): I now have a new life goal of becoming the bee. You mentioned democracy, and not knowing much about government until 2002, but from 2002 to today, you won eight elections that I could count. So many of the elections, over 800 million people vote in India. What does it take to win an election like that, and to win an election of 1.4 billion people where you get to represent those people, the biggest democracy in the world? Narendra Modi (02:04:17): Well, I’ve been actively involved in politics for years. Before stepping into active politics, my focus was primarily on organizational work. This also included managing elections and strategizing campaigns, so that was where I dedicated my time. For 24 years, the people of Gujarat and India have placed their trust in me to lead with unwavering dedication and a deep sense of duty. I try to fulfill the sacred duty entrusted to me by the people I revere as divine. I remain committed to honoring their trust, ensuring it never falters. And they see me for what I truly am. Narendra Modi (02:05:18): My government is committed to ensuring welfare schemes reach every citizen. Every scheme must reach its intended beneficiaries. Every beneficiary must be treated equally. No one should face discrimination on caste, creed, faith, wealth, or ideology. We must strive to ensure the well-being and prosperity of everyone. This way, even those not directly benefiting, never feel left out or treated unfairly. They find comfort in knowing they too will benefit in due course. This fosters a deep sense of trust, and trust is the cornerstone of my governance model. Narendra Modi (02:06:09): Secondly, my governance flows beyond the ebb and flow of elections. My governance is rooted in the people, not the polls. It is committed to the well-being of my citizens and the greater good of the nation. As you may know, I had once set out on a quest for spiritual awakening, so now I revere my nation as the Divine itself, and I now revere the people as a manifestation of the Divine. Like a devoted priest, my heart is set on serving the people. I don’t distance myself from the people. I live among them as one of them. And I tell everyone I work with, if you work hard, I will work harder. People see this and it builds trust. Besides, I have no conflicts of interest. I have no friends or relatives who stand to gain from the position I hold. The common man appreciates this lack of vested interests, and that’s probably just one reason why. Narendra Modi (02:07:21): Moreover, I come from a party with millions of dedicated volunteers. Volunteers who are completely devoted to the welfare of India and its citizens. They have had no stake whatsoever in politics. They’ve held no title, nor strayed where influence holds sway. My party is blessed with millions of volunteers who work tirelessly. I am proud to belong to the world’s largest political party, and it’s not like my party has been around forever. It reflects the hard work of millions of volunteers. Their selfless service is widely recognized and valued by the community. It fortifies people’s trust in the BJP, echoed in the election results. I never tallied our election triumphs, but we have had people’s blessings. Lex Fridman (02:08:18): I was wondering if you could speak to the incredible logistics, that blew my mind, of running the elections in India. So there’s a lot of interesting anecdotes that arise, for example, that no voter should be more than two kilometers away from a polling station. The result of that is you have these stories, of voting machines having to be carried to remote regions of India, is really incredible. Just every single voter counts, and the machinery of having 600 plus million people vote. Is there some anecdote you could speak to that is particularly impressive to you? Or maybe you could speak generally to the logistics of what it makes to run an election that big, a democracy that big. Narendra Modi (02:09:10): First and foremost, I am truly grateful for your insightful question. Anyone who believes in democracy should listen to what I’m about to share with you. We often discuss election results, but all the behind the scenes work is overlooked. Let’s take the recently concluded 2024 general elections as an example. There were 980 million registered voters. Each of those voters had a registered ID, and all the necessary details in a vast database. And this number is twice the entire population of North America. It even surpasses the total population of the entire European Union. Out of the 980 million registered voters, 646 million people ventured out, and braved the intense heat of May, determined to cast their votes. Temperatures soared to 40 degrees in some areas, yet they chose to go, and the size of this voter base is double the population of the United States. Narendra Modi (02:10:36): We had more than a million polling booths. Can you fathom all the manpower involved in this? My country has more than 2,500 registered political parties. This staggering figure, with such a vast array of political parties, has the power to leave the entire world in awe. My country has more than 900 round-the-clock news channels. There are over 5,000 newspapers published daily. They each play a role in upholding democracy in their own way. Even the humblest villagers here embrace technology with remarkable swiftness. While some other countries take months to declare election results, we announced the results within a day, despite the mind-boggling number of voters. Narendra Modi (02:11:35): And you were spot on in saying that even the remotest villages have polling stations. We even use helicopters to transport polling stations. I believe Arunachal Pradesh has the highest altitude polling booth on record. In Gujarat, a polling booth was set up in the Gir Forest for just one voter, who was in the middle of nowhere, but we ensured a polling booth was set up for them. All I mean to say… Narendra Modi (02:12:03): … ensure the polling booth was set up for them. All I mean to say is that we truly leave no stone unturned in our unwavering commitment to strengthening democracy, ensuring that we are always fully prepared and election ready no matter the circumstances. I firmly believe that India’s Election Commission sets a global standard as a benchmark for conducting free and fair elections. It is the Apex decision-maker. This in itself is such a remarkable story that the world’s top universities should consider it a case study. They should analyze the management behind it as a valuable learning example. Given the sheer number of voters, can you truly grasp the immense depth of political awareness? All of this will make for an excellent case study for the younger generation worldwide. Lex Fridman (02:13:07): To me, I love democracy. This is one of the main reasons I love the United States, but there’s just nothing quite as beautiful as democracy when it functions in India. Like you said, 900 million people registered to vote. It really is a case study. It’s beautiful to see that many people come together willingly, passionately casting a vote for some person to represent them like they’re putting their heart in that. It’s really important for a person to feel like their voice is going to be heard. It’s beautiful. Speaking of which, you are loved by a lot of people. You are one of the most powerful humans in the world. Do you sometimes think about whether this much power has a corrupting effect on your mind, especially across the many years that you’ve been in power? Narendra Modi (02:14:03): Well, I don’t think the word powerful quite reflects the journey of my life. I can never claim to be powerful. For all I am is a humble servant, I even identify myself as not the Prime Minister, but the prime servant, and service is the guiding principle of my work ethic. Narendra Modi (02:14:28): As far as power is concerned, it is something I have never bothered about. I entered politics not to play power games, but to serve. Rather than seeking power, I stay committed to doing and getting work done. I am more focused on productivity than power. I have always dedicated myself to serving the people. I have always devoted myself to bringing about a positive change in their lives. Lex Fridman (02:15:04): Like you mentioned, you work a lot. You give your whole soul to your work. Do you ever get lonely? Narendra Modi (02:15:20): Look, I never experience loneliness because I am an ardent believer in the philosophy of one plus one, and this philosophy of one plus one is aligned with my moral compass, and whenever I am asked to elaborate on this outlook, I say, the first one represents Modi and the other one represents the Almighty. I am never alone for he is always there to keep me company. This is just how I function. Having wholeheartedly embraced the ideals of Swami Vivekananda, I firmly believe that service to mankind is service to God. For me, the nation itself is divine and mankind is a reflection of the divine. I walk this path with the conviction that serving the people is serving the divine. That’s why the very notion of struggling with loneliness has never even remotely crossed my mind. Narendra Modi (02:16:41): Like at the time of pandemic, with the lockdown and traveling restrictions in place, I came up with a way to make the most of my time. I designed a governance model that operated seamlessly through videoconferencing. I kept myself occupied with remote work and virtual meetings. Narendra Modi (02:17:16): Another thing I did was to connect with the people I had worked with throughout my life. Among my party’s volunteers nationwide, I made a list of those who were 70 and older. Some of the volunteers had very humble beginnings and came from very modest backgrounds. I personally called every volunteer aged 70 and above. I made it a point to inquire about their health and their family’s well-being. I inquired about how their area was coping. I asked these questions to make sure they were doing well. This allowed me to build rapport with them, and we would go down the memory lane. They were touched that the Prime Minister would check on them in the pandemic. Narendra Modi (02:18:08): I made around 40 calls every day without fail. I carried on with this throughout the pandemic. It gave me the chance to reconnect and relive old memories with familiar faces. Loneliness is never a concern for me, as I always find ways to stay engaged, and I have long been at peace with myself. The time I spent in the Himalayas have helped me develop this. Lex Fridman (02:18:35): I’ve heard from many people that you are the hardest worker they know. What’s your philosophy behind that? Maybe you put in crazy hours every single day. Do you ever get tired? What’s your source of strength and perseverance through all of that? Narendra Modi (02:18:56): Look, first of all, I don’t believe I’m the only one working. I look at the people around me and always think these people work harder than I do. When I think about farmers, I realize how hard they work. They toil and sweat under the open sky day after day. When I look at our country’s soldiers, I think about how many hours someone spends working tirelessly in snow, deserts, or even underwater day and night. When I see a laborer, I think about how hard they’re working. I always think about how hard our mothers and sisters work in every family for the happiness of the family. They’re the first to wake up and the last to go to bed, taking care of everyone in the family, while also managing social responsibilities. Thinking of all this, I’m in awe of how hard people work. So I think, “How can I sleep? How can I relax?” So naturally the motivation is right in front of my eyes. Those very things around me keep me motivated. Narendra Modi (02:20:04): Secondly, my responsibilities keep pushing me forward. The responsibilities entrusted to me by my fellow citizens always remind me that I’m not here to enjoy privileges. I will always give it my absolute best. Perhaps there are a couple of things I may not accomplish, but there will never be a lack of effort or hard work from me. When I was campaigning in 2014, I had made a promise first in Gujarat and later across India. I promised my fellow citizens that I will never fall behind in hard work for my country. Secondly, I promised I would never act with bad intentions, and thirdly, I vowed I’d never do anything for personal gain. Narendra Modi (02:21:05): Today it’s been 24 years. For such a long period, the people have entrusted me as head of government. I’ve continuously held myself to these three standards, and I still live by them today. My inspiration comes from serving 1.4 billion people from understanding and fulfilling their aspirations and addressing their needs. I’m always determined to do as much as I can, work as hard as possible. Even today, my energy remains just as strong. Lex Fridman (02:21:42): Me as an engineer, as a person who loves mathematics, I have to ask Srinivasa Ramanujan is an Indian mathematician from a century ago. He’s widely considered to be one of the greatest mathematicians of all time. Self-taught, grew up in poverty. You have often spoken about him. What do you find inspiring about him? Narendra Modi (02:22:07): Look, I deeply respect him, and everyone in my country respects him as well, because I strongly believe there’s a deep connection between science and spirituality. If you closely observe many scientifically advanced minds, you’ll find they’re often spiritually advanced too. They’re not disconnected from spirituality. Srinivasa Ramanujan once said that his mathematical ideas came from the goddess he worshiped, meaning ideas emerge from spiritual discipline, and discipline is more than just hard work. It means fully devoting yourself to a task and completely immersing yourself into it so much that you become one with your work. Narendra Modi (02:23:10): You see, the more open we are to new and different sources of knowledge, the more new ideas we’ll have. I think it’s important for us to clearly understand the difference between information and knowledge. Some people mistakenly confuse information with knowledge, carrying around large amounts of information, but I don’t believe information alone equals knowledge. Knowledge is something deeper. It gradually evolves through processing, reflection and understanding. Recognizing this difference is important in how we handle both. Lex Fridman (02:23:49): You have a reputation for being a decisive leader. So can you walk me through on this topic of ideas, how you make decisions? What’s your process? So for instance, when facing a high stakes choice with no clear precedence, a lot of uncertainty, having to balance input, how do you make decisions? Narendra Modi (02:24:13): There are many factors to my decision making. First, I’m perhaps the only politician in India who has stayed overnight in around 85 to 90% of the districts across the country. This was before my current role. I used to travel extensively. I learned a lot from those experiences. They gave me firsthand knowledge of the ground realities and grassroots level issues, not something asked or heard or learned merely from books. Secondly, from a governance perspective, I carry no baggage of any kind. I don’t carry any baggage that weighs me down or forces me to act a certain way. Thirdly, I have a simple yardstick for decisions. My country first. I always question if what I’m doing harms my nation in any way. Additionally, Mahatma Gandhi once said that, if you’re ever unsure when making a decision, think of the poorest person’s face. Remember them and ask yourself, “Will this help them?” Then your decision will be right. That wisdom always guides me, remembering ordinary citizens and considering how my actions affect them. Narendra Modi (02:25:54): Another factor in my approach is that I’m very well-connected in my administration. My officials know this well and probably feel overwhelmed by it, by the fact that my information channels are numerous and are very active. Because of that, I receive lots of insights from various sources. So when someone comes to brief me, that’s not my only source of information. I always have additional perspectives available to me. Narendra Modi (02:26:37): Another thing, I maintain a learner’s mindset. Suppose I’m not familiar with something and an official explains it to me. I approach them like a student and ask, “Can you clarify this? How does it work? Then what happens next and how?” Whenever I have different information, I deliberately play devil’s advocate and ask challenging questions. I thoroughly analyze the issue from multiple angles, hoping that careful evaluation will yield something valuable. Then once I converge toward a decision or action that is worth taking, I share the idea informally with like-minded people just to gauge their reactions and see how they respond, gathering insights and feedback before moving forward, until finally, I have a strong conviction that my decision is right. Narendra Modi (02:27:46): This entire decision-making process doesn’t actually take much time. My speed is very fast. Let me share an example. How did I make decisions during COVID? I had Nobel Prize winners advising me, giving countless economic examples from around the world. They’d say, “This country is doing this, that country did that. You should do it too.” Renowned economists constantly bombarded me with suggestions. Political parties pressured me relentlessly, urging me to spend huge amounts of money, but I didn’t act immediately. I paused and reflected. What exactly should I do? Then considering the unique conditions of my own country, I made a clear decision. I wouldn’t let the poor sleep hungry. I wouldn’t allow social tensions to arise over basic daily needs. Narendra Modi (02:28:43): These core principles guided my approach. The entire world was in lockdown. Global economies were collapsing. Everyone pressured me to empty the treasury, print more currency and flood money everywhere, but I decided that this was not the right economic route to follow. And so instead, the path I chose, after carefully listening to experts, understanding their opinions without opposing them and combining their advice with my own country’s situation and my personal experiences, created a system that worked effectively. As a result, when the whole world suffered from severe inflation immediately after COVID, India did not. Narendra Modi (02:29:38): Today, my country is steadily advancing at a rapid pace, emerging as one of the fastest growing major economies in the world. The main reason is that during that crisis, with patience and discipline, I resisted the temptation to apply every global theory blindly. We didn’t worry about what newspapers would say, whether they’d praise or criticize. Ignoring all that, I stayed focused on basic fundamentals, and by doing so, we succeeded and kept moving ahead. So ultimately, my economy benefited as well. My approach has always been to stay focused on these fundamentals. Narendra Modi (02:30:22): Another strength is my risk-taking capacity. I don’t worry about potential losses for myself. If something is right for my country, for the people, I’m always prepared to take the risk. Secondly, I take ownership of my decisions. If something goes wrong, I don’t ship blame to others. I stand up, take responsibility, and own the outcome. When you take ownership, your team also becomes deeply committed. They know this person won’t let us down, won’t abandon us. He’ll always stand with us because they see I’m making honest decisions, not for myself, but for the nation. I’ve openly told the country from the start, I’m human. I can make mistakes, but I won’t act with bad intentions. People remember those words clearly. Even if something doesn’t go as planned, they trust that Modi’s intentions were right. They think he probably meant to do something good even if it didn’t work out. So society sees and accepts me just as I am. Lex Fridman (02:31:35): You gave a powerful speech on AI a few weeks ago at the AI Summit in France. In it you spoke about the talent pool for AI engineers in India. I think it’s probably one of the biggest pools of brilliant engineers in the world. So how can India become the leader in the space of AI? Currently lags behind the United States. What does it take for India to start winning and leading the world in AI? Narendra Modi (02:32:09): One thing I’m about to say might sound strong, and it may even upset some people, but since you’ve asked, I’ll speak openly from my heart. No matter what the world does with AI, it will remain incomplete without India. I’m making this statement very responsibly. Tell me, you’ve heard my speech at the AI Summit in Paris on global cooperation. What do you think? Can anyone develop AI entirely on their own? What is your perspective on this? Lex Fridman (02:32:56): You gave, actually, in your speech a brilliant example of the positive impact of AI and the limitations of AI. I think the example you gave is when you ask it to generate an image of a person writing with their left hand- Narendra Modi (02:33:17): Left hand. Lex Fridman (02:33:17): … it’s always going to generate a person writing with their right hand. So in that way, the West creating an AI system where India is not part of that process is always going to generate the person with the right hand is an essential part of what the world is historically, but especially in the 21st century. Narendra Modi (02:33:43): I agree. I believe AI development is fundamentally a collaboration. Everyone involved supports one another through shared experiences and learning. India isn’t just developing theoretical AI models. It is actively working on and bringing to life AI-driven applications for very specific use cases to ensure that GPU access is available to every section of society. We have already created a unique marketplace-based model to ensure its broad accessibility. A significant mindset shift is taking place in India, though historical influences, traditional government procedures or the lack of strong support infrastructure made us appear as lagging behind to others. Narendra Modi (02:34:49): Take 5G for example. The world initially believed we were far behind, but once we started, we became the fastest nation globally to roll out comprehensive 5G networks. Recently, an American company executive visited me and shared his experiences about this very fact. He told me that if I were to advertise in the US for engineers, I would only receive enough applicants to fill a single room at best. But if I do the same in India, even a football field wouldn’t be enough to hold them. This indicates that India has access to an extraordinarily vast pool of talent, and that’s our greatest strength. After all, artificial intelligence is fundamentally powered, shaped, and guided by human intelligence. Without genuine human intelligence, AI can’t thrive or progress sustainably, and that real intelligence exists abundantly in India’s youth and talent pool, and I believe that’s our greatest asset. Lex Fridman (02:36:10): But also if you look, many of the top tech leaders, first of all, tech talent, but tech leaders in the US are of Indian origin, Sundar Pichai, Satya Nadella, Aravind Srinivas. You’ve met with some of them. What spirit of their Indian origins do you think they carry in them that enables them to be so successful? Narendra Modi (02:36:35): Look, Indian culture emphasizes that there should be equal respect for the place where you’re born and the place where you work. There should be no difference. As much as there is dedication to the land of birth, there should be the same sense of dedication to the land of work. You should always give your best wherever you are. Because of these rich cultural values, every Indian strives to give their best effort, regardless of their role or position. They don’t wait until they’re in senior roles, even in smaller roles. Narendra Modi (02:37:10): Secondly, they never get involved in anything questionable or unethical. They tend to remain dedicated to what’s right and ethical. Their nature is collaborative. They easily get along with others, eventually for success. Just having knowledge isn’t enough. The ability to work effectively as part of a team matters significantly more. Understanding people and harnessing their abilities is an incredibly valuable skill. Narendra Modi (02:37:38): Generally, people raised in India, especially those coming from joint families and brought up in an open society, find it easier to lead complex tasks and large teams effectively. That’s why today, in major corporations across the globe, you’ll find Indians holding key leadership positions. The problem-solving abilities, along with the analytical thinking of Indian professionals are truly exceptional. I believe this capability is so strong, it makes Indians globally competitive and extremely valuable on the international stage. This is the reason why in fields like innovation, entrepreneurship, startups and boardrooms, you’ll find Indians achieving extraordinary results everywhere. Narendra Modi (02:38:37): Take our space sector, for example. Previously, it was entirely government-controlled, but just a couple of years ago, I opened it up to the private sector, and now we already have 200 startups working in space technology. Moreover, our missions like Chandrayaan are extremely cost-effective. India’s Chandrayaan mission costs less than what Hollywood spends making a single blockbuster film. So when the world sees how cost-effective our work is, they naturally think why not partner with India? This automatically generates respect for Indian talent globally. I believe this is a hallmark of our civilizational ethos. Lex Fridman (02:39:28): You spoke about this human intelligence. Do you worry that AI, artificial intelligence, will replace us humans? Narendra Modi (02:39:38): It’s true that in every era, a competitive atmosphere was created between technology and humanity. At times, it was even portrayed as conflict. It was often portrayed as if technology would challenge human existence itself. But every time, as technology advanced, humans adapted and stayed a step ahead. It has always been the case. After all, it is humans who find the best ways to use technology to their advantage. I believe that with AI, humans are now being forced to reflect on what it truly means to be human. This is the real power of AI. Because of the way AI functions, it has challenged how we perceive work itself. But human imagination is the fuel. AI can create many things based on that, and in the future it may achieve even more. Still, I firmly believe that no technology can ever replace the boundless creativity and imagination of the human mind. Lex Fridman (02:41:05): I agree with you. It does make me and a lot of people wonder what makes humans special because it seems that there’s a lot that makes humans special. The imagination, the creativity, the consciousness, the ability to be afraid, to love, to dream, to think outside of the box, outside of the box of the box of the box, take risks, all of those things. Narendra Modi (02:41:32): Now, look, humans have an innate ability to care for each other, the natural tendency to be concerned about one another. Now, can someone tell me, is AI capable of this? Lex Fridman (02:41:46): This is one of the big open questions of the 21st century. Every year you host the Pariksha Pe Charcha where you interact directly with young students and give them advice on how to prepare for exams. I watched a bunch of them. So you give advice on how to succeed in exams, how to manage stress, all those kinds of things. Can you explain at a high level the different exams that students in India need to take in their education journey and why it’s so stressful? Narendra Modi (02:42:19): By and large, a strange mindset has developed in society today. Even schools measure their success by students’ rankings. Families too feel pride when their child achieves a high rank because they believe it improves their educational and social status. This mentality has resulted in increased pressure on children. Kids also began feeling that their entire lives depend on 10th and 12th grade exams. Narendra Modi (02:42:53): We’ve introduced significant changes in our new education policy to address this issue. But until those changes take effect on the ground, I feel another responsibility. If our children face challenges, it’s my duty to listen to them, understand them, and ease their burden. In a way, when I conduct Pariksha Pe Charcha, I get insights directly from the students, understand their parents’ mindset, as well as the perspectives of people in the educational field. So these discussions don’t just benefit the students. They benefit me too. Narendra Modi (02:43:37): Exams are valuable for assessing knowledge in a specific domain, but they can’t become the sole measure of someone’s overall potential. Many people may not score high academically, yet can hit a century in cricket because that’s where their true strength lies. When the focus shifts to actual learning, scores tend to naturally improve. Narendra Modi (02:44:08): I remember when I was a student, I had a teacher whose learning techniques still greatly appeal to me today. He would give us children specific instructions. To one child he would say, “Tomorrow, bring exactly 10 chickpeas from home.” To another, he might request, ” Bring 15 grains of rice. No more. No less.” A third child could be told, “Bring 21 mung beans. Precisely that number.” Different students got different quantities and varieties. So each child would think, “I need to get exactly 10.” Counting them at home helped them memorize numbers naturally. Then they’d learn what chickpeas were, and after returning to school, they’d pool it all. The teacher would then ask, ” Take out 10 chickpeas, three chickpeas, two mung beans-“ Narendra Modi (02:45:03): … take out 10 chickpeas, three chickpeas, two mung beans. This way children learned math and could identify chickpeas and mung beans effortlessly. I’m talking about early childhood education here. Such learning techniques educate children without burdening them, and we’ve incorporated similar methods into our new education policy. Narendra Modi (02:45:22): When I was in school, I observed one of my teachers using an innovative idea. On his very first day, he placed a diary on the table and said, “Whoever arrives earliest each morning will write one sentence in this diary along with their name.” The next student would then need to write a related sentence. Narendra Modi (02:45:52): At first, I’d rush to school very early every day. Why? So that I could write the first sentence. I once wrote something like, “Today’s sunrise was magnificent. It filled me with energy.” I’d write my name and whoever arrived after me had to write something connected to the sunrise as well. Narendra Modi (02:46:20): After a few days, I realized my creativity wasn’t improving much from this. Why? Because I’d arrived with the fixed thought already in mind and simply write it down. So I decided I’d start going last instead. What happened then was that I’d read what others had written first and then try to give my very best. Narendra Modi (02:46:48): As a result, my creativity began to improve even more. Sometimes teachers do these small simple activities that greatly impact your life. These experiences combined with my own background in organizational work, made human resource development a key area of focus for me. Narendra Modi (02:47:14): That’s why I engage with children through events once or twice each year and over time, these efforts have resulted in a book that’s benefiting thousands of children serving as a valuable reference for them. Lex Fridman (02:47:27): Can you speak a little bit more by way of advice to students of how to be successful on their path in their career, how to find the career and how to find success in India and just to all the people across the world who find inspiration in your words? Narendra Modi (02:47:50): I believe that whatever task you get, if you perform that task with complete dedication and sincerity, they inevitably become an expert sooner or later, and their enhanced capabilities open doors to success. Narendra Modi (02:48:23): While working, one must continually strive to improve their skills and should never underestimate their ability to learn. When someone constantly neglects their learning ability, they limit their growth, but those who look beyond their tasks and observe what others around them are doing, their capacity can double or even triple. Narendra Modi (02:48:54): To young people I’d say this clearly, there’s no need to feel discouraged. There’s certainly some task out there destined just for you. Don’t worry. Focus on enhancing your skills and opportunities will come. Narendra Modi (02:49:15): You may think, “I wanted to be a doctor, but became a teacher. My life is wasted.” Thinking like that won’t help you at all. All right, you didn’t become a doctor, but as a teacher, you can shape 100 doctors. Narendra Modi (02:49:28): If you had become a doctor, you’d serve only your patients. But now, as a teacher, you can inspire students to fulfill their dreams of becoming doctors so that both you and your students can together serve millions of patients. Then he gains a new perspective on life. Narendra Modi (02:49:44): “I couldn’t become a doctor so I was miserable and I was unhappy being a teacher, but now I realize as a teacher, I can create doctors.” Connecting your life to a greater purpose brings a sense of inspiration and meaning. I have always believed that God has given everyone unique capabilities. Never lose faith in your own abilities. You should always maintain trust in your own abilities. Keep believing in yourself and trust that when the opportunity comes, you’ll perform and you’ll succeed. That confidence makes a person deliver results. Lex Fridman (02:50:26): How do those students deal with stress, with struggle, with difficulties along that path? Narendra Modi (02:50:33): Parents must first understand that life is not just about taking exams. Families should understand that their children aren’t trophies meant to be displayed or models to show off in society. It’s not about saying, “Look, my kid scores so high.” Parents really need to stop using their kids just as status symbols. Narendra Modi (02:50:55): Secondly, students should always keep themselves well-prepared beforehand. Only then can they appear for exams feeling stress-free and confident. They should have complete trust in themselves and their abilities. Narendra Modi (02:51:12): Sometimes I see students panic over the smallest issues during exams. They take papers or other things, and when their pen suddenly stops working causing anxiety, sometimes they feel uneasy thinking, “Oh no, I don’t like sitting next to this person.” If the bench wobbles, their whole attention goes there, indicating self-doubt. Narendra Modi (02:51:33): Those lacking confidence constantly keep looking for distractions. But if you are confident and have genuinely worked hard, just take a minute, take some deep breaths, relax your mind and refocus your attention calmly. Narendra Modi (02:51:48): Slowly read through the questions and allocate your time systematically. “I have this amount of time I’ll dedicate these minutes per question.” In my experience, students who regularly practice writing test papers can easily overcome such situations without any trouble at all. Lex Fridman (02:52:05): And you said, “Always focus on learning.” What’s your approach to learning? What advice can you give on how to learn best, not just when you’re young, throughout your life? Narendra Modi (02:52:19): Let me share a personal example with you. I used to learn a lot from reading, but these days, more and more, I learn by being fully present. Whenever I meet someone, I am fully present in the moment. I give them my full attention. This complete focus allows me to grasp new concepts quickly. Narendra Modi (02:52:48): When I’m with you, I’m fully present, grounded in the moment. No calls or messages can pull me away from this moment with you. I am fully present focused on the here and now. That’s why I always believe this is a habit everyone should embrace. Narendra Modi (02:53:06): It will sharpen your mind and improve your learning ability. Besides, knowledge alone cannot light the way. You must immerse yourself in the flow of practice. You cannot master driving merely by reading the life stories of great drivers. You must get behind the wheel and take the road yourself. Narendra Modi (02:53:26): You must dare to take risks. You can never master the road if fear of accident or death holds you back. I truly believe that those who live in the present are the ones who live their life to the fullest. That’s because they know that every moment lived has already slipped into the past. Narendra Modi (02:53:53): So you must embrace the moment before it fades into the past. Otherwise, chasing the future only turns the present into the past. It’s not a trade worth making. Most people stress so much about the future that their present quietly slips away. Before they know it the moment has already faded into the past. Lex Fridman (02:54:19): Yeah, I’ve heard a lot of stories of you having meetings with people and it’s usually all the distractions, there’s no distractions. It’s just two human beings just like this and just focused on the moment and the interaction. That’s a really beautiful thing. And today really is a gift that you would give that focus to me, so thank you. Lex Fridman (02:54:42): Let me ask maybe a difficult, maybe a human question. Do you contemplate your mortality? Are you afraid of death? Narendra Modi (02:54:54): Can I ask you a question instead? Lex Fridman (02:54:57): Sure. Narendra Modi (02:54:58): I have a very interesting question. Life and death are two sides of a coin, but which of the two is more certain? Lex Fridman (02:55:09): Death. Narendra Modi (02:55:10): Exactly. Now, with that out of the way, we know for a fact that life itself is a whispered promise of death, and yet life is also destined to flourish. So again, in the dance of life and death, only death is certain, so why fear what is certain? That’s why you must embrace life instead of fretting over death. Narendra Modi (02:55:43): That’s how life will evolve and flourish, for it is uncertain. That’s why you must commit to enriching, refining and elevating your life so you can live fully and with a purpose before death comes knocking. Narendra Modi (02:56:04): That’s why you must let go of the fear of death. After all, death is inevitable and there’s no use worrying about when it will arrive. It will arrive when it’s meant to. Lex Fridman (02:56:17): What gives you hope about the future? Not just of India, but all of human civilization, all of us humans here on earth? Narendra Modi (02:56:27): Well, I am an optimist at heart. Pessimism and negativity are simply not ingrained in my mindset. They don’t align with the way I think. That’s why I always gravitate toward the bright side instead. Narendra Modi (02:56:48): If we take a moment to reflect on the history of mankind, we see the incredible crisis humans have overcome with resilience and strength. We also see the major changes humanity has embraced to evolve with the times, and this continuous transformation has carried on for millennia. Narendra Modi (02:57:10): In every era, it is in human nature to adapt to the ever-flowing current of change. And while our progress has gone through cycles of ups and downs, it is those people who can break free from the constraints of these historical cycles and outdated thinking patterns. Narendra Modi (02:57:35): It is they who can help humanity achieve extraordinary positive breakthroughs with an unshackled speed and grace transcending the limitations of the old way of doing things by embracing change. Lex Fridman (02:57:56): In this moment, I was wondering if you could guide me perhaps through a Hindu prayer or meditation for a few moments. I learned, I’m trying to learn the Gayatri Mantra. In my fast I was trying to do the chants. Perhaps I could try chanting. You could tell me about the importance of this mantra and maybe others in your life, in your spirituality? Should I try? Narendra Modi (02:58:31): Yes, please. Lex Fridman (02:58:34): [foreign language 02:58:34]. How did I do? It’s okay? Narendra Modi (02:58:51): You did great. [foreign language 02:58:58]. This mantra is dedicated to the radiant power of the sun and is considered a powerful tool for spiritual enlightenment. Narendra Modi (02:59:13): Many mantras in Hindu philosophy are deeply intertwined in some intricate and interesting ways with science and nature, each woven into different facets of life. Chanting mantras on a daily basis brings profound and lasting benefits. Lex Fridman (02:59:41): In your own spirituality and your quiet moments, when you are with God, where does your mind go? What role do mantras play when you’re fasting, when you’re just alone with yourself? Narendra Modi (02:59:57): The word meditation has been overused to the point that it feels like a cliché. In Indian languages, we usually refer to it as dhyan. If I associate dhyan to meditation, it might seem burdensome to some. One might think, “This is too difficult. I’m not an enlightened being.” But it’s not rocket science. It just means freeing yourself from distraction. Narendra Modi (03:00:32): For example, even when you’re in class, your mind wanders to recess. All you think about is lunch, not the lesson. Meditation is simply being present in the moment. I recall an incident from my time living in the Himalayas. There I encountered this wise sage. He taught me a simple practical technique. It was nothing spiritual. Narendra Modi (03:01:06): There are several little streams in the Himalayas. He positioned a large leaf to catch water from one of those streams and placed an upside down bowl below so water would drip rhythmically from the leaf onto the bowl. Narendra Modi (03:01:33): He asked me to focus only on the dripping water, ignoring all other sounds. “Ignore the chirping birds and the soft rustle of the breeze.” He would place the leaf and I would meditate there for hours. I felt my mind slowly tuning into the rhythmic sounds of the water droplets falling onto the bowl like a melody guiding me into deep focus. Narendra Modi (03:02:09): And it’s not like I was chanting mantras or reciting God’s name. I like to call it the divine resonance. It was by tuning into that divine resonance that I learned the art of concentration. This practice slowly evolved into meditation. Sometimes you happen to stay at a fancy hotel, you get a lavish, luxurious room. The decor is impeccable and you have been wholeheartedly fasting, but there’s a dripping faucet in the bathroom. That faint sound is enough to make a luxurious room feel worthless. Narendra Modi (03:02:57): At times, we realize the value of concentration in life’s inner journey. We come to appreciate the difference a little bit of concentration can make. One very interesting concept comes to mind from our scriptures. Narendra Modi (03:03:21): Since we spoke about life and death, I would like to quote a mantra, [foreign language 03:03:28]. In other words, all life is part of a complete circle, and this mantra emphasizes the path to achieve that completeness. Narendra Modi (03:03:44): Similarly, Hindus never focus solely on individual well-being. [foreign language 03:03:52]. In other words, we wish for the well-being and prosperity of all. [foreign language 03:04:00]. This mantra encompasses the idea of universal well-being and prosperity. Narendra Modi (03:04:11): And you know how this mantra ends? [foreign language 03:04:13]. Every Hindu mantra ends on the same note. Peace, peace, peace. These ancient and powerful rituals born in India have emerged from thousands of years of the spiritual practice of sages. They connect us to the essence of life. Lex Fridman (03:04:40): [foreign language 03:04:40]. Thank you for this honor. Thank you for this incredible conversation. Thank you for welcoming me to India, and I can’t wait to break the fast with some Indian food tomorrow. Thank you so much, Prime Minister. This was an honor. Narendra Modi (03:04:56): I am thankful for the opportunity to have this conversation with you. After fasting for two days I recommend you ease into eating slowly and I hope you reap great benefits from this fasting experience. Narendra Modi (03:05:11): I’ve explored several new realms of thought for the first time ever with you today. I had long kept those thoughts tucked away within myself, but today you brought those thoughts to light. I hope [inaudible 03:05:30]. Lex Fridman (03:05:29): Thank you. Narendra Modi (03:05:30): I hope your viewers may enjoy this. It was a great pleasure speaking with you. Thank you. Lex Fridman (03:05:38): Thank you. Thank you for listening to this conversation with Prime Minister Narendra Modi. And now, let me ask you some questions and try reflect on and articulate some things I’ve been thinking about. If you would like to submit questions or get in touch with me for whatever reason, go to lexfridman.com/contact. Lex Fridman (03:05:58): First, let me give a shout out to the amazing team around the Prime Minister. Everyone was super kind, excellent at what they do, efficient, great communication, and just great people all around. Lex Fridman (03:06:13): And since I spoke English and Prime Minister Modi spoke Hindi, I have to comment on the interpreter who was doing simultaneous interpreting for both of us. She was absolutely amazing. I can’t sing her enough praises. From the equipment used to the quality of the translation, to just the human touch of it all. Lex Fridman (03:06:36): And in general, my travels around Delhi and India revealed to me some early glimpses of what felt like another world, almost like another planet, different culturally from anything I’ve experienced before. A chaos of human interactions, out there, big dynamic personalities and characters. Lex Fridman (03:06:58): Obviously, India’s composed of many distinct subcultures and Delhi represents just one slice. Much like neither New York or Texas or Iowa alone represent America. They’re all different flavors of America. Lex Fridman (03:07:13): On my visit, I walked around and rode rickshaws everywhere, just aimlessly wandering the streets, looking to talk to people about life. Of course, like many places on earth, there are always some people, especially those that have something to sell, who will at first see me as a tourist, a foreign traveler, one with some money to spend. Lex Fridman (03:07:36): Like always, I avoided such shallow interactions and went straight past the small talk to the meaningful conversations. Shooting the shit about what they love, what they fear, what kind of hardship and triumph they’ve experienced in their lives. Lex Fridman (03:07:52): I think the cool thing about people anywhere on earth is they quickly do see the real you past the facades that strangers put up for each other, if you’re vulnerable and honest enough to let them. And I tried to do just that and I should say that for the most part, everyone was super kind in the genuine human way. Lex Fridman (03:08:17): Even when they didn’t speak English, it was always easy to understand. Probably more than any other peoples I’ve interacted with in India, people’s eyes, faces, body language, all communicate a lot of information, a lot of emotion, not reserved at all. Lex Fridman (03:08:33): When I traveled through Eastern Europe, for example, in contrast, reading a person is much tougher. The meme does have some truth to it. There’s often a protective layer between the heart of the person and the outside world. In India, it’s all there on full display. So I had a lot of epic conversations and interactions as I walked around Delhi for a couple of weeks. Lex Fridman (03:08:58): In general, on the topic of reading people, I do believe the eyes can often say more than words can. We humans are a fascinating bunch. There really is a deep turbulent ocean behind the surface waves we show the world. In some sense, what I try to do in conversations, on and off the mic, is to get to that depth. Lex Fridman (03:09:20): Anyway, the few weeks I spent in India were a magical experience. Traffic alone was a wild time, like the world’s most difficult test for self-driving cars. Lex Fridman (03:09:32): It reminded me of watching nature documentary videos of swarms of fish when it’s thousands of them swimming around at insane speeds, seemingly in complete chaos. And yet when looking at the big picture of it it all works like a perfectly tuned orchestra. Lex Fridman (03:09:52): I will, most certainly, travel around India with my friend Paul Rosalie in the near future, maybe with some other friends all around from the north of India to the south. Lex Fridman (03:10:04): Now, allow me to also comment about one of the books that first drew me toward India and to its deep history of philosophical and spiritual traditions. The book is Siddhartha by Hermann Hesse. Lex Fridman (03:10:19): I first read most of Hesse’s major work as a teenager, but then reread them again through the years. It first found me, Siddhartha, when I was immersed in a very different kind of literature of Dostoevsky, Camus, Kafka, Orwell, Hemingway, Kerouac, Steinbeck and so on. Many of these explore the same human condition that puzzled me when I was a young man and still puzzles me today, even more so. Lex Fridman (03:10:49): But Siddhartha was my introduction to the Eastern way of looking at these puzzles. It was written by Hermann Hesse. And by the way, please allow me this pronunciation of his last name. I’ve heard some people say Hesse, but my whole life I’ve always said Hesse. Lex Fridman (03:11:04): So, anyway, it was written by Hermann Hesse, a German-Swiss Nobel Prize winning writer during one of the darkest periods of his own life. His marriage was failing, World War I has shattered his pacifist ideals and he suffered from debilitating headaches, insomnia, and depression. Lex Fridman (03:11:22): During this period, he began psychoanalysis with Carl Jung, which, in part, led him to explore Eastern philosophies as a way to heal his fractured psyche. Hesse immersed himself in translations of ancient Hindu and Buddhist texts studying the Upanishads and the Bhagavad Gita. Lex Fridman (03:11:42): And so, the writing of Siddhartha was in itself, for him, a journey that paralleled that of the main character in the book. Hesse started writing the book in 1919 and finished three years later experiencing an extensive psychological crisis in the middle. The book follows Siddhartha, a young man in ancient India, as he leaves behind wealth and comfort to search for meaning. You can feel his personal struggle in every page. Siddhartha’s restlessness, his dissatisfaction with conventional wisdom, his need to find truth, the direct experience. Lex Fridman (03:12:20): Again, the book wasn’t simply a philosophical exploration for Hesse, it was psychological survival. He was writing his way out of suffering and towards his own enlightenment. I won’t go into a deep analysis of the book here, but I will mention two key lessons I took away and carry with me to this day. Lex Fridman (03:12:41): First lesson comes from the scene in the book that to me is one of the great scenes in all of literature. Siddhartha is sitting by a river just listening, and in that river he hears all of life. All sounds, all voices, all of time, past, present, future, flowing together as one. Lex Fridman (03:13:03): That scene gave me the experience and the notion that while in some grounded human sense, the linear arrow of time does exist. In another sense, time is a kind of illusion that, in fact, everything exists simultaneously. That our lives are both momentary and eternal. It is hard to describe these ideas with words. I think they must be experienced as personal revelations. Lex Fridman (03:13:32): I’m reminded of the fish story that David Foster Wallace, another one of my favorite writers, described in a commencement speech 20 years ago. The story goes, “Two young fish are swimming along when they encounter an older fish swimming the opposite way. The older fish nods and says, ‘Morning boys, how’s the water?’ The young fish swim on, and eventually one turns to the other and asks, ‘What the hell is water?'” Lex Fridman (03:14:04): The illusion of the forward progress of time is water in this metaphor. As humans, we’re fully immersed in it, but enlightenment, in part, involves being able to step back and get a glimpse at another deeper perspective on reality where all things are inextricably interconnected across both time and space. Lex Fridman (03:14:28): Another key lesson from the novel that was especially formative to me as a young man was that one should not blindly follow others or learn about the world exclusively through books. But rather forge your own path and thrust yourself into the world where the lessons of life can only be learned by experiencing them directly. Lex Fridman (03:14:49): And every experience, both positive and negative, mistakes, suffering and even seemingly wasted time is all an essential part of growth. To this point, Hesse draws a distinction between knowledge and wisdom. Knowledge can be taught by others. Wisdom can only be gathered through experiencing the full mess of life yourself. Lex Fridman (03:15:13): In other words, the path to understanding isn’t through rejection of the world, but through complete immersion in it. Those are my early steps in seeing the world through the lens of Eastern philosophy. But many of Hesse’s books had an impact on me. I would recommend to read Demian, when you are younger, Steppenwolf, when you are older, Siddhartha throughout your life, especially in moments of crisis, and The Glass Bead Game if you want to take on Hesse’s magnum opus, that rigorously explores the ways the human mind and human civilization can engage in the pursuit of knowledge, wisdom, and meaning. Lex Fridman (03:15:55): But Siddhartha is the only one I’ve returned to more than twice. In my own life, when faced with a difficult situation, I often return to the moment in the book when Siddhartha is asked what skills he possesses, and his answer is simply, “I can think, I can wait, I can fast.” Lex Fridman (03:16:15): Let me elaborate. Indeed, for the first part, “I can think.” As Marcus Aurelius said, “The quality of your life is determined by the quality of your thoughts.” For the second part, “I can wait.” Patience and waiting often is indeed the optimal decision when facing a problem. Time does bring clarity and depth of understanding. Lex Fridman (03:16:39): For the third part, “I can fast.” When needed, being able to live and flourish with less is a prerequisite of being free when the mind, the body, and society all are trying to put you in cages. Lex Fridman (03:16:56): All right, friends, now sadly, our time together in this episode has come to a close. As always, thank you for being here and thank you for your support through the years. Lex Fridman (03:17:08): Let me leave you with a few words from the Bhagavad Gita. “He who experiences the unity of life, sees his own self in all beings and all beings in his own self and looks unto everything with an impartial eye.” Thank you for listening. I hope to see you next time.

本集資源與出處